Untold Ref Review Everton 0 – MU 1

Posted on by WalterBroeckx

—————————————–

“Making the Arsenal” – the book of Arsenal’s decline and rebirth

 Untold Arsenal on Twitter @UntoldArsenal

—————————————–

By Ref Reviewer 04

We had ref Halsey at Goodison Park for the game Everton – Manchester United. Let us see how he did this game.

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight

4

 OTHER Cleverly Byliadetinov C Push advantage signalled

1

1

6

 OFFSIDE MU C

1

1

6

 OTHER Fellaini Park C Trip

1

1

8

 OTHER Coleman Evra C Late tackle

1

1

11

 OTHER Rooney Osman NC Push in the back

0

0

11

 OFFSIDE MU C

1

1

14

 OTHER Vidic Osman NC Came flying in the back from a distance using arms and knee hitting the Everton player

0

0

16

 OFFSIDE MU C

1

1

19

 GOAL MU C Correct goal

1

3

22

 OTHER Baines Park NC Baines came flying in and Park had to jump to save his legs nothing given

0

0

26

 OTHER Rodwell Jones C Trip

1

1

26

 YELLOW Rodwell C A cynical foul after losing the ball

1

2

33

 OTHER Hibbert Welbeck C Trip

1

1

34

 OTHER Vidic Osman C Blocks the striker

1

1

38

 OFFSIDE Everton NC Clearly onside

0

0

39

 OTHER Fletcher Fellaini C Blocks the striker

1

1

43

 OTHER Coleman C Handball

1

1
Half time

13

16
CORRECT

76,47%

80,00%
YELLOW

1

1

100,00
RED

0

0
PENALTY

0

0
GOAL

1

1

100,00
OTHER

1

1

100,00

3

3

100,00
OFFSIDE

3

4

75,00
Second half

46

 OTHER Chicarito Jagielka C Push

1

1

47

 OTHER Saha Jones C Late challenge

1

1

49

 OTHER Fellaini Fletcher NC Fletcher was tugging the shirt of Fellaini who pushed Fletcher away to free himself. Shoud have given the first foul

0

0

52

 OTHER Chicarito C Handball

1

1

52

 OFFSIDE Everton C

1

1

57

 OTHER Hibbert Chicarito C Push in the back

1

1

58

 OTHER NC Throw in to Everton given to MU

0

0

62

 OTHER Rooney Barkley NC Push not given

0

0

64

 OFFSIDE MU C

1

1

66

 OTHER Coleman Evra NC Late challenge – advantage given

0

0

67

 yellow Coleman C Coleman gets a yellow card for his earlier tackle on Evra

1

2

68

 PENALTY Rooney/Vidic Fellaini NC Rooney and Vidic just hold Fellaini to the ground by pushing him on his shoulders. Ref doesn’t see it

0

0

70

 OTHER Fellaini Park C Trip

1

1

72

 OTHER Heitinga Park C Trip

1

1

72

 OFFSIDE MU C

1

1

83

 OTHER Valencia Barkley C High foot

1

1

86

 OFFSIDE Fellaini C

1

1

87

 OTHER Fellaini Nani C Trip

1

1

92

 PENALTY Evra Gueye NC Evra runs in the back of the striker who was attempting to go for the ball. Evra brings him down.

0

0

92

 RED Evra NC It was a goal scoring opportunity so a red card should have been given

0

0

94

 OTHER Valencia Baines C Baines runs in he back of Valencia. This time the ref gives the foul

1

1

95

 OTHER Fellaini Jones C Trip and stamp

1

1

95

 yellow Fellaini C Nasty kick after the foul correct card

1

2

96

 OTHER Evans Vellios C Push

1

1
2nd half score
TOTAL

17

19
% CORRECT

70,83%

59,38%
YELLOW

2

2

100,00
RED

0

1

0,00
PENALTY

0

2

0,00
GOAL

0

0
OTHER

1

2

50,00

3

7

42,86
OFFSIDE

4

4

100,00
TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL

30

35
% CORRECT

73,17%

67,31%
YELLOW

3

3

100,00
RED

0

1

0,00
PENALTY

0

2

0,00
GOAL

1

1

100,00
OTHER

2

3

66,67

6

10

60,00
OFFSIDE

7

8

87,50
Correct calls For Everton

12

40,00%
For MU

18

60,00%
Total correct calls

30
Wrong calls Against Everton

9

81,82%
Against MU

2

18,18%
Total

11

 

A mixed game for the ref. An excellent first half was followed by a mediocre second half and this is a friendly judgement.

Everton could and should have had two penalties. The first one was when both Rooney and Vidic just took Fellaini by his shoulders and pushed him down on the ground using their hands and arms. The Everton player could not move and the MUdefender could head the ball away.  The other one in extra time when Gueye was brought down by Evra when he was going to the ball. Evra was coming from behind on the striker so he had his eyes on him all the time and should have avoided contact. He didn’t avoided it and ran in to his back. Seconds later the ref gave a simple free kick in the middle of the field to MU for a somewhat similar running in the back of a player.

Another moment that didn’t went unnoticed was when the first assistant had to stop after hurting his back and Phil Dowd stepping up to do the last minutes as the assistant. This was also a reason why 6 minutes of extra time was awarded because it took a while before the game could restart.

——————————-

Untold Arsenal – the (fairly) complete index

Untold Arsenal on Facebook here

Recent Posts

7 Replies to “Untold Ref Review Everton 0 – MU 1”

  2. They will need a sugar daddy just to stay up if the Refs keep giving those sort of decisions.

  3. I thought Rooney got away with a shove on their goal, taking out the defender who could have cleared the ball that Chicharito headed into the net.

  4. i think you miss about the goal from chicarito.
    before goal rooney push jagielka who trying to
    heading the ball.. shame on ref. i think that’s blatant foul.
    and the quality of the ref more exposed in 2nd half.. you
    need to watched again bro.. maybe we can use the tecnology
    to make the game more fair… viva fair play…

  5. Another game in which Manu get treated softly and the opposition gets all the wrong calls!

  6. It’ll be this way, especially in this year that’s destined to be the Fergie XXth; especially when there is danger that ManShitty has shown signs of usurping the throne. 80:20 on wrong calls against ManUre’s opponent. How many ManU matches this season has the Ref Team done to date which show this level of disproportion? Is a running tally being kept? Insisting on sounding like a broken record, only video replay will stop this. The problem is that someone or group of blogs need to start the petition, before the usual woe is me at the end of the season with Lord Football hoisting the trophy.

  7. About the Utd goal and the Rooney push.
    Based on the video evidence I could not make up for 100% sure that Jagielka missed the ball because of a push. The only angle that could give 100% conclusive evidence would have been from the right to the Everton goal.

    It certainly gave the impression that there was contact but like I said I cannot be 100% sure that this was the reason that Jagielka missed the ball.

    So I had to give it as a correct goal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *