Untold Ref Review : Man City 3 – Newcastle 1 – an excellent game from the ref

By Ref Reviewer 04

The game Manchester City – Newcastle was under the guidance of ref Foy. How was his game?

Min	Type	Foul from	On	C/NC	Comment	points	weight
5	OTHER	R. Taylor	Richards	C	Trip	1	1
6	OTHER	Aguero		C	Handball	1	1
14	OTHER	Lescot	Simpson	C	Push in the back	1	1
17	OTHER	Richards	Gutierezs	C	Pull	1	1
19	OTHER	Jonas	Balotelli	C	Trip advantage given	1	1
22	OTHER	Lescot	Balotelli	NC	Clear push in his back when in the air and loses his balance	0	0
26	OTHER	Yaya	R. Taylor	C	Push	1	1
28	OFFSIDE	MC		C	No replay shown	1	1
33	OTHER	Milner	Cabaye	C	Trip	1	1
34	OFFSIDE	Aguero		NC	Not given, keeper has to kick the ball out because of him following the ball	0	0
35	OFFSIDE	MC		C		1	1
36	OTHER	Yaya	R. Taylor	C	Push and for the second time Yaya protest the decisions by the ref who lets it go	1	1
36	YELLOW	Yaya		NC	Twice is once too much. Argueing the refs decisions with gestures should be booked this season	0	0
41	PENALTY	R. Taylor		C	Taylro tries to block a shot with his arms wide open, correct penalty	1	3
41	GOAL	MC		C	Correct goal	1	3
42	OTHER	Simpson	Balotelli	C	Push	1	1
44	GOAL	MC		C	Correct goal	1	1
46	OTHER	Gutierez	Aguero	C	Kick from behind	1	1
46	OTHER	Balotelli	Gutierezs	C	First the man and then the ball is a foul	1	1
	Half time					16	20
			CORRECT			84,21%	83,33%
	YELLOW				0	1	0,00
	RED
	PENALTY				1	1	100,00
	GOAL				2	2	100,00
	OTHER				1	1	100,00
	Total				4	5	80,00
	OFFSIDE				2	3	66,67
	Second half
47	OTHER	Gutierez	Milner	C	Pull but advantage given as the counter is on	1	1
47	OTHER	Richards	Ben Arfa	C	Trip	1	1
48	OTHER	Jonas	Aguero	C	Trip	1	1
56	OTHER	Kompany	Ba	C	Push	1	1
62	OTHER	Newc?	Milner	NC	Push not given	0	0
65	OFFSIDE	MC		C	Wait and see	1	1
66	OTHER	Balotelly	Guthrie	C	Kick from behind	1	1
66	yellow	Balotelly		NC	Should at least have said a word as this was a tackle from behind	0	1
67	OFFSIDE	MC		C		1	1
69	OFFSIDE	Newcastle		C	Came back from offside	1	1
69	OTHER			C	S.Taylor is bleeding so must leave the field to get medical assistance	1	1
70	PENALTY	Ben Arfa	Richards	C	Little push but also made contact with the legs	1	3
71	GOAL	MC		C	correct goal	1	1
80	OFFSIDE	MC		C	just offside	1	1
81	OFFSIDE	MC		C	no replay	1	1
88	OTHER	Richards	Jonas	C	Trip	1	1
89	GOAL	Newcastle		C	correct goal	1	3
90	OTHER	Perch	Dejong	C	Little trip a bit late	1	1
93	OTHER	Colicini	Silva	C	Push	1	1
94	OTHER	Richards	BA	C	Push	1	1
			2nd half score
	TOTAL					18	23
	%		CORRECT			90,00%	92,00%
	YELLOW				0	1	0,00
	RED
	PENALTY				1	1	100,00
	GOAL				2	2	100,00
	OTHER				1	1	100,00
	Total				4	5	80,00
	OFFSIDE				4	4	100,00
			TOTAL SCORE
	TOTAL					34	43
	%		CORRECT			87,18%	87,76%
	YELLOW				0	2	0,00
	RED				0	0
	PENALTY				2	2	100,00
	GOAL				4	4	100,00
	OTHER				2	2	100,00
	Total				8	10	80,00
	OFFSIDE				6	7	85,71
	Correct calls		For MC		13	40,63%
			For Newcastle		19	59,38%
			Total correct calls		32
	Wrong calls		Against MC		1	20,00%
			Against Newcastle		4	80,00%
			Total		5
	Total fouls made by		MC		19	59,38%
			Newcastle		13	40,63%
			Total		32

 

Well the only thing we can say is that he had a very good game. A score of 87% is very high and he made just a few mistakes. Not really big mistakes in fact. Only 5 wrong calls in the whole game.

The only negative point I had to say about ref Foy in this game was that he didn’t book 2 City players in this game and he should have booked them according to the instructions. But it didn’t influence the outcome of the game.