Arsenal News
Arsenal News & Transfers
As featured on NewsNow: Arsenal newsArsenal News 24/7

Arsenal News, Only Arsenal, Blogs, Transfer News

Archives

March 2017
M T W T F S S
« Feb    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Untold Ref Review: Man C 3 – Stoke 0; is Yaya Toure untouchable?

By Ref Reviewer 04

For the game Manchester City – Stoke City we had ref Dean in charge. Let us see what the final score was we could give him.

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight
2 OFFSIDE MC C 1 1
7 OTHER Walters Lescott C Push 1 1
9 OTHER Lescott Jones C Push and holding 1 1
10 OTHER NC Throw in given to MC, was for Stoke 0 0
13 OTHER Kompany Jerome NC Obstruction 0 0
15 OTHER Whitehead Richards NC Sliding in, frontal tackle got ball and man. Frontal tackle is always a foul ref 0 0
16 OTHER Clichy Walters C A bit of holding 1 1
19 OTHER Shotton C Handball 1 1
22 OTHER Jerome Lescott C Held him but advantage given 1 1
23 OTHER Richards Upson C Came in late 1 1
23 YELLOW Richards C Came in wild and got the defender 1 2
29 OFFSIDE MC NC Not given 0 0
29 GOAL MC NC Aguero was in front of the ball when Kompany took the shot. The fact that the keeper touched the ball is not important. He gained advantage from his position when he score. Goal should have been ruled out. 0 0
34 OTHER Jones Yaya NC Held the defender, no advantage signalled 0 0
36 GOAL MC C Correct goal 1 3
38 OTHER Jerome Lescott C Push 1 1
41 OTHER Wilson Nasri C Trip 1 1
Half time 11 14
CORRECT 64,71% 63,64%
YELLOW 1 1 100,00
RED
PENALTY
GOAL 1 2 50,00
OTHER 1 2 50,00
Total 3 5 60,00
OFFSIDE 1 2 50,00
Second half
52 OTHER Clichy Shotton C Little push 1 1
53 OTHER Stoke? Kompany C Advantage given 1 1
54 GOAL MC C correct goal 1 3
58 OTHER Woodgate Johson NC Push in the back not given 0 0
62 OTHER Walters Yaya C Holding 1 1
62 YELLOW Walters NC Holding an opponent and not letting go is a yellow card 0 0
62 RED Yaya NC Yaya Toure kicks at Walters who is not happy with this and the players stand nose to nose. An attempt to kick an opponent (even twice) is always a red card. Ref just talks to the players 0 0
71 OTHER Fuller Lescott C Came a bit late 1 1
71 YELLOW Fuller C Coming late on the defender 1 2
73 OTHER Aguero Upson C Not visible agree with the ref 1 1
74 OTHER Huth C Handball (similar to the handball from Richards in the Arsenal which was not given by Dowd then) 1 1
76 OTHER Stoke? MC? NC Obstruction given by the assistant but ref signals advantage. Posession is not the same as advantage ref 0 0
78 PENALTY Huth C Hanball not given but it was a shot from very close and the hands close to the body 1 3
80 OTHER Huth Aguero C Push and shove 1 1
89 OTHER Johnson Pennant C Held him by the shirt 1 1
89 YELLOW Johnson C As the instructions tell 1 2
2nd half score
TOTAL

12

18

% CORRECT

75,00%

72,00%

YELLOW

2

3

66,67

RED

0

1

0,00

PENALTY

1

1

100,00

GOAL

1

1

100,00

OTHER

3

3

100,00

Total

7

9

77,78

OFFSIDE
TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL

23

32

% CORRECT

69,70%

68,09%

YELLOW

3

4

75,00

RED

0

1

0,00

PENALTY

1

1

100,00

GOAL

2

3

66,67

OTHER

4

5

80,00

Total

10

14

71,43

OFFSIDE

1

2

50,00

Correct calls For MC

12

52,17%

For Stoke

11

47,83%

Total correct calls

23

Wrong calls Against MC

5

50,00%

Against Stoke

5

50,00%

Total

10

Total fouls made by MC

9

39,13%

Stoke

14

60,87%

Total

23

Imp. Wrong against MC

0

0,00%

Stoke

1

100,00%

1

 

The first goal of City was the result of a not given offside against Aguero who was past the last defender and in front of the ball when Kompany took his shot on goal. The assistants are giving MC some important decisions it seems.

I wonder if for some reason Yaya Toure is somewhat untouchable for the referees? By a coincidence I also did the game Chelsea – Manchester City and in this game he kicked Mata when the ball was out of play and no red card was given and no ban was given. Again in this game Yaya Toure kicked twice at his opponent after he was being pulled back and again nothing was done by the ref and as far as I know nothing was done by the FA.

For a game with little history it was in fact a poor referee performance because ref Dean managed to get a low score in what was a rather easy game.

Follow us on Twitter @Untold Arsenal

————————————————————–

Hands up if you thought we would be fourth this year

Match Preview – oh hell its Atrkinson.  Arsenal v QPR

—————————————————————————————

Referees update – are they listening to Untold at last?  Surely not!

Referees close their official web site, but make a step in the direction we’ve been asking for

Comments are closed.