Arsenal News
Arsenal News & Transfers
As featured on NewsNow: Arsenal newsArsenal News 24/7

Arsenal News, Only Arsenal, Blogs, Transfer News

Archives

November 2017
M T W T F S S
« Oct    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  

Untold Ref Review: Sunderland 1 – Man City 0. Ref helps Sunderland at end

By Ref Reviewer 04

Ref Kevin Friend did the game between Sunderland and Manchester City. Did he have a good game?

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight

2

OTHER Sun? MC? C Advantage given, leads to a corner

1

1

7

OFFSIDE MC C Assumed correct

1

1

7

OTHER De Jong Cattermole C Tripped

1

1

7

YELLOW De Jong C Came late, no chance playing the ball, promising attack

1

2

11

OFFSIDE MC C Assumed correct

1

1

16

OTHER Barry Sessegnon C Held him

1

1

19

OTHER Larson De Jong C High foot

1

1

22

OTHER Lescot Bendtner NC Pushed in his back

0

0

33

OTHER Zabaleta? C Handball, assumed correct

1

1

36

OTHER Zabaleta? Sun? NC Tackle from behind, didn’t get the ball and Sunderland lost possession

0

0

40

OTHER Gardner Johsnon C No foot foul but he held his arm around the City player

1

1

41

OTHER Zabaleta Bendtner C Trip

1

1

43

OTHER Bendtner De Jong C Push

1

1

45

OTHER Barry Sun? NC Push not given

0

0

Half time

11

12

CORRECT

78,57%

80,00%

YELLOW

1

1

100,00

RED
PENALTY
GOAL
OTHER

1

1

100,00

2

2

100,00

OFFSIDE

2

2

100,00

Second half

51

OTHER Toure Bendtner NC Toure clipped the foot of Bendtner who tried to stay on his feet but because of being brought out of balance he played the ball in the feet of a City player. Ref should have given the initial foul

0

0

53

OTHER Barry Sessegnon NC Push not given

0

0

54

OTHER Larsson Aguero C Pulled him back

1

1

59

OTHER Kolarov Sessegnon NC Stretched his leg very far so Sessegnon could only jump to avoid impact and then went down. Nothing given bij de ref. leading to a chance to City

0

0

60

OTHER Kolarov Sessegnon C Obstruction

1

1

60

OTHER Kompany Bendtner C Kompany all over Bendtner

1

1

66

OTHER Larsson Aguero C Held him for a while to prevent him go past him on the left wing

1

1

66

YELLOW Larsson C Holding the opponent for a longer period is punished with a yellow and Larsson had already had been spoken to before this

1

2

69

OTHER Kilgallon Dzeko C Push and trip

1

1

75

OTHER Richards Colback C Trip in the Sunderland penalty area

1

1

82

OTHER NC Ref gives a goalkick to Sunderland, Kilgallon was the last one whou touched the ball

0

0

86

OTHER Sessegnon Barry C Advantage given

1

1

89

OFFSIDE Richards NC Silva takes a shot and when he shoots Richards is offside. The ball bounces of the keeper to him and Richards heads against the cross bar.

0

0

90

OTHER Sessegnon Lescott C During a replay assumed correct

1

1

93

OFFSIDE Sunderland NC Ji was offside when the ball was played to him

0

0

93

GOAL Sunderland NC Ji scores from this offside position. Should have been cancelled

0

0

2nd half score
TOTAL

9

10

% CORRECT

56,25%

52,63%

YELLOW

1

1

100,00

RED
PENALTY
GOAL

0

1

0,00

OTHER

1

2

50,00

2

4

50,00

OFFSIDE

0

2

0,00

TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL

20

22

% CORRECT

66,67%

64,71%

YELLOW

2

2

100,00

RED

0

0

PENALTY

0

0

GOAL

0

1

0,00

OTHER

2

3

66,67

4

6

66,67

OFFSIDE

2

4

50,00

NEW TEST 1st half 2nd half Total %
WRONG NC F SUN 1

0

2

2

NCF SUN 2

0

0

0

NCF SUN 3

0

1

1

Total normal

0

2

2

FA SUN

22,22%

Total important

0

1

1

FA SUN

100,00%

General total

0

3

3

FA SUN

30,00%

WRONG NC F MC 1

3

4

7

NC F MC 2

0

0

0

NC F MC 3

0

0

0

Total normal

3

4

7

FA MC

77,78%

Total important

0

0

0

FA MC

0,00%

General total

3

4

7

FA MC

70,00%

TOTAL NORMAL WRONG

9

TOTAL IMPORTANT WRONG

1

GENERAL TOTAL

10

CORRECT CF SUN 1

6

3

9

CF SUN 2

1

0

1

CF SUN 3

0

0

0

Total normal

6

3

9

Total important

1

0

1

CORRECT CF MC 1

4

5

9

CF MC 2

0

1

1

CF MC 3

0

0

0

Total normal

4

5

9

Total Important

0

1

1

Foul HO

4

6

10

FOUL AW

9

7

16

 

The last seconds was the difference between a very good game and not that good one.

The first half was excellent and a good example on how to stamp authority on the game. The first tackle that was over the line was immediately punished with a yellow card. And from this moment in the 7th minute both teams knew they had to be careful. The result was a highly committed game with a very stubborn defending Sunderland but never did they cross the line and went in with flying or dangerous tackles. All in all not much fouls in the game. Maybe thanks to the early yellow?

In the last seconds of extra time Sunderland scored from an offside position. The assistant was clearly not level with the second last defender and because of that he had the wrong angle and it will have looked for him that the Sunderland player was onside. He wasn’t as was clear to see after 10 seconds of replays. A perfect example on how within 10 seconds a goal can be given as correct or can be cancelled as not correct.

Also Manchester City could have scored from an offside goal. But Richards put the ball against the crossbar from an offside position that wasn’t given also.  The two assistants having a bad day in the second half

3 comments to Untold Ref Review: Sunderland 1 – Man City 0. Ref helps Sunderland at end

  • Abhishek Kumar

    Hi Walter

    I liked this review as much as any other review, I think that the previous summary which told the cumulative right or wrong calls was better.

    I dont mind the new format but please keep the old ones also with the new ones. Sometimes you dont have to read everything and you can just look at the overall stats and understand the summary.

  • walter

    Abishek,

    I will try to give the old summary back its place and just put the two together in the same article. We still count also the old summary in our review so it is just a matter of putting it online in fact.

  • dan

    Is this Kalou transfer correct?? Really cant see or hope this one goes through. I cant see him adding to the team and what’s the deal with Park?

    Please please please I’m praying this is paper talk.