Arsenal News
Arsenal News & Transfers
As featured on NewsNow: Arsenal newsArsenal News 24/7

Arsenal News, Only Arsenal, Blogs, Transfer News

Archives

December 2017
M T W T F S S
« Nov    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Untold Ref Review: Tottenham 1 – 0 Sunderland

Woolwich Arsenal, the club that changed football.  Have your name in the book as an official sponsor.  Updated information here

 

By Ref Reviewer 03

Tottenham hosted Sunderland and the ref was Mike Dean.  As DogFace has pointed out, Harry Redknapp’s sides have done very well under Mike Dean.  Let’s see how they fared.

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight
3 OTHER Parker   C Handball 1 1
5 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Assumed correct 1 1
8 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Assumed correct 1 1
8 OTHER Wickham Gallas C Backed in under him 1 1
11 OTHER Richardson Modric NC Shove – not given 0 0
20 OFFSIDE Wickham   C Assumed correct 1 1
22 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Correct 1 1
22 OTHER Gallas Wickham NC Climbed over him – not given but Sun. kept possession 0 0
27 OTHER     NC Dean stopped play 2 minutes to let Tottenham substitute Lennon 0 0
29 OTHER Walker   NC Raised boot – not given 0 0
35 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Assumed correct 1 1
38 OTHER Van der Vaart C Assumed correct 1 1
38 OTHER Gallas Wickham C Push 1 1
40 OFFSIDE Sessegnon C Assumed correct 1 1
41 OTHER King   C Handball 1 1
44 OTHER Walker Sessegnon C Foul 1 1
48 OTHER Walker Bardsley C Lunged in, leg extended, studs showing 1 1
48 YELLOW Walker   NC This was a dangerous lunge – could have been sent off, Dean just talked to him 0 0
               
  Half time         13 13
      CORRECT   72,22% 68,42%
               
  YELLOW       0 1 0,00
  RED       0 0  
  PENALTY       0 0  
  GOAL       0 0  
  OTHER       1 1 100,00
               
          1 2 50,00
               
  OFFSIDE       6 6 100,00
               
  Second half          
               
47 OTHER Pavlyuchenko C Handball 1 1
48 OTHER Walker Bendtner C Shove 1 1
49 OTHER Assou-Ekotto Vaughan C Lost possession then blatantly tripped opponent 1 1
49 YELLOW Assou-Ekotto C Unsporting behaviour 1 2
50 OTHER Richardson Modric C Push 1 1
50 YELLOW Richardson C Kicked ball away after whistle 1 2
59 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Assumed correct 1 1
61 GOAL     C Pavlyuchenko – goal okay 1 3
62 YELLOW Parker   NC Dived trying to win a free kick – should have been booked 0 0
63 OTHER Larson Modric NC Modric used arm to hold off defender which threw himself off balance – wrong call 0 0
64 OTHER Sandro Sessegnon NC Pulled his arm back then dispossessed him – not given 0 0
65 OTHER Walker Richardson NC Push – not given 0 0
66 OTHER Vaughan Pavlyuchenko C Trip 1 1
66 YELLOW Vaughan   C Missed with his left foot then caught him with his right 1 2
69 OTHER Gallas Bendtner NC Jumped knee into Bendtner to win header – not given 0 0
72 OTHER Colback Sandro C Pulled him back 1 1
74 OTHER Assou-Ekotto NC Handball not given – blocked Sunderland clearance and allowed Tottenham a shot 0 0
78 PENALTY     C Unintentional handbal by Sund. from close range – good no call 1 3
78 OTHER Gardener Van der Vaart C Pushing/pulling 1 1
80 OTHER Walker Sessegnon NC Blatantly shoved off the ball – not given 0 0
80 OTHER Walker Brown NC Shove on defender – not given 0 0
80 OTHER Bramble Pavlyuchenko C Trip on edge of box 1 1
80 PENALTY     C Not given – very close call as to if foul was on the line or just outside – right not to give it if in doubt 1 3
80 OTHER Gardener   NC Didn’t respect 10 yards – free kick should have been retaken 0 0
83 OTHER Gallas Bendtner NC Ran into him as he headed ball – not given 0 0
87 OFFSIDE Adebayor   C Assumed correct 1 1
91 OTHER Gardener Rose C Trip 1 1
92 OTHER Walker McClean C Pushed off ball – not given 0 0
92 OTHER Livermore Vaughan NC Challenged for ball unfairly, studs showing 0 0
92 OTHER Larson Parker NC Trip – not given 0 0
               
      2nd half score    
  TOTAL         17 26
  %   CORRECT   56,67% 65,00%
               
  YELLOW       3 4 75,00
  RED       0 0  
  PENALTY       2 2 100,00
  GOAL       1 1 100,00
  OTHER       0 2 0,00
               
          6 9 66,67
               
  OFFSIDE       2 2 100,00
               
      TOTAL SCORE    
               
  TOTAL         30 39
  %   CORRECT   62,50% 66,10%
               
  YELLOW       3 5 60,00
  RED       0 0  
  PENALTY       2 2 100,00
  GOAL       1 1 100,00
  OTHER       1 3 33,33
               
          7 11 63,64
               
  OFFSIDE       8 8 100,00
               
  NEW TEST 1st half 2nd half Total   %
  WRONG NC F TOT 1 3 10 13    
    NCF TOT 2 1 1 2    
    NCF TOT 3 0 0 0    
    Total normal 3 10 13 FA TOT 81,25%
    Total important 1 1 2 FA TOT 100,00%
    General total 4 11 15 FA TOT 83,33%
               
  WRONG NC F SUN 1 1 2 3    
    NC F SUN 2 0 0 0    
    NC F SUN 3 0 0 0    
    Total normal 1 2 3 FA SUN 18,75%
    Total important 0 0 0 FA SUN 0,00%
    General total 1 2 3 FA SUN 16,67%
               
    TOTAL NORMAL WRONG 16    
    TOTAL IMPORTANT WRONG 2    
    GENERAL TOTAL   18    
               
  CORRECT CF TOT 1 3 6 9    
    CF TOT 2 0 2 2    
    CF TOT 3 0 1 1    
    Total normal 3 6 9    
    Total important 0 3 3    
               
  CORRECT CF SUN 1 10 5 15    
    CF SUN 2 0 1 1    
    CF SUN3 0 2 2    
    Total normal 10 5 15    
    Total Important 0 3 3    
               
    Foul TOT 8 12 20    
    FOUL SUN 2 7 9    
               
  OLD VERSION          
  Correct calls For Tottenham 9 37,50%  
      For Sunderland 15 62,50%  
      Total correct calls 24    
               
  Wrong calls Against Tottenham 3 16,67%  
      Against Sunderland 15 83,33%  
      Total   18    
               
  Total fouls made by Tottenham 20 68,97%  
      Sunderland 9 31,03%  
      Total   29    

The first half had a couple of things stand out.  First in the 25th minute, Aaron Lennon suddenly became hurt and needed to be substituted.  Mike Dean stopped play for 2 minutes allowing Tottenham all the time they needed to get Pavlyuchenko ready to substitute Lennon.  The ref should have had Lennon receive treatment off the pitch and continued play.

At the end of the first half, Tottenham’s young right back, Kyle Walker, made an awful lunge on Phillip Bardsley, who had just pushed the ball to the side.  Walker lunged in leg-extended, studs-up, and caught Bardsley slightly in the foot.  Personally, I would have sent off Walker for this kind of challenge, though I suppose most EPL refs would probably only give it as a yellow, and I marked it as such.  Nonetheless there is no question that this was a yellow card offense at the very least yet the only punishment Walker got was a talking to by Mike Dean.

In the early stages of the 2nd half, Dean correctly made a couple of bookings for minor incidents (1 to each side), and then in the 61st minute Tottenham opened the scoring with a correctly scored goal by Pavlyuchenko.

From that point on calls for the most part went against Sunderland although there were a couple of minor penalty shouts for Tottenham correctly turned down, one being an unintentional handball from close range, the other being a trip on Pavlyuchenko just outside the penalty area.

Overall wrong decisions favoured Tottenham by a margin of 15 to 3, and Mike Dean’s score on the day rated only at 62.50%.

12 comments to Untold Ref Review: Tottenham 1 – 0 Sunderland

  • Mahdain

    the first day of arry`s trial has finished and is not looking good for him..apparently he made a bank account with his dog`s name rosie47 and could serve upto six months if found guilty

  • Mandy Dodd

    Lol, that dog thing is amusing!
    Just hope the jury does not consist of Mike Dean, or any members that form the vast majority of the UK media!

  • WalterBroeckx

    thanks for the link Mahdain

  • bjtgooner

    Strange name for a dog?

  • Arun

    A regular performance by dean to make sure his loved ones don’t drop two points.
    Off the topic, seriously ,which ediot runs the mediawatch section on official site.Why on earth, have they posted a link to nasri’s interview ????

  • dan

    U know what i’m talkin about hey Arry, off shore accounted named after the dog.

  • Mahdain

    no problem walter just wanted every one to read the proceedings for themselves 🙂

  • dan

    No mention of our beloved Arry in the tabloids, me wonders why???

  • Mahdain

    @dan ofcourse they will shut up about it..he is their pal afterall and ofcourse a saint who can do nothing wrong and who manages the best team to ever play football

  • Mandy Dodd

    If he really is guilty of taking bungs, is his position untenable with the Tiny Totts and England?

    Maybe it is all innocent and the account was just there to ensure the welfare of his canine friend, a noble thing to do surely!

    Think we need a massive campaign to support the “peoples alleged tax evader”, the alleged bung taker of hearts, he was only allegedly taking off those who could afford it after all, a sort of east end Robin Hood if you will squire! gawd bless’im

  • bjtgooner

    @Mahdain

    This is amost interesting link. It will be interesting to see how it is reported over the next few weeks and also what moves are pulled to try to stop ‘Arry getting a red card!