- Which teams have been the best and which the most successful
- The ten lessons Arsenal have given to football
By Tony Attwood
There was an interesting comment about refereeing in England in the New York Times recently in which they said, in relation to the issue of bringing in referees from overseas (a topic we touched on recently), “The Premier League would also have to be prepared to pay more to attract officials from overseas. It has steadily increased the money it gives Pro Ref, handing over £27.6million for the 2024-25 season, but this still represented only a tiny fraction of the league’s £6.8bn turnover (based on Deloitte figures). Meanwhile, referees’ pay in England is being squeezed, not increased.”
That final comment is both worrying and frustrating, but also one that gives us some insights. And this is not because paying more automatically gets a better service, but because it is the most obvious way of getting more referees and better refereeing into the Premier League, and possibly to stop the nonsense of Arsenal being refereed by the same man five or more times in a season.
For as we have argued here time and time again, the ideal way to ensure there is no corruption in terms of referee favouritism and the like, is for no referee ever to oversee more than two matches of the same club in any one season..
In a previous article I noted (having just found out myself) that a few countries do bring in refs from other parts of the world to oversee occasional matches, but we don’t do that in the Premier League. The reason is of course because refereeing in the Premier League is based on different rules, norms and “understandings” in the Premier League, which referees elsewhere don’t abide by. Or to put that into the English translation, “The foreign refs don’t understand the English game.”
This ludicrous situation has arisen because a series of reinterpretations of the laws of the games by English referees, which (it is said) allows for games to become more free-flowing, faster “and thus a way of delivering more goals and more entertainment for the crowd”.
Now the solution to this problem and indeed the entire problem of refereeing in the Premier League is simple: train up more referees and then to spread their work of the referees more evenly so that no referee ever oversees matches involved the same club more than twice in a season (once at home, and once away).
Then having done that, start giving our referees experience of games in Europe. This could start by having referees going to Europe to observe games, and then slowly to become involved in games and learning just how far English football has deviated from the European game.
It has been suggested that there could be a language problem in relation to this as most PL referees only speak English, but watching football matches here, it does seem to me that 95% of decisions are indicated by the whistle and hand gestures. The only time the players seek to discuss issues with the ref is when the player is frustrated by something the referee has done. But the rules suggest this should only be a conversation with the captain, and really the referee only needs to learn a few words in the native language, such as “offside” and “foul”. Besides there is no telling what nationality the player questioning the referee is going to be, and therefore what language he speaks.
Then from that point on, the referees themselves could set up some sort of organisation which worked on unifying the rules pertaining to football, at least across leagues across Europe if not across the world. Certainly there is a need for this reform in relation to Europe, so that once the rules of football are applied uniformly across the Continent, we could be assured that European referees would be overseeing European matches at the same standard and in the same way in all European matches.
Now this notion of a reform is so clear and obvious, we really do have to ask why it has never been implemented before now. Why are the refereeing associations of the top leagues in Europe not meeting together and ensuring that the referees are applying the rules in the same way?
In looking into this it became clear to me that most European leagues believe that the referees in England don’t know the rules of the game. Now that is hardly a surprise!
You will also hardly be surprised to read that football is the most popular sport in virtually every single country in Europe, nor the fact that the majority of World Cups have been won by countries from within Europe. Over half of the World Cups have been won by European nations. What’s more when it comes to club football the five dominant leagues are all in Europe: in England, Spain, Germany Italy and France.
But what is happening is that when players move from a club in continental Europe into the Premier League, the first thing that they have to do is both to learn English and then to learn how the rules are interpreted differently in the Premier League from the rest of Europe.
Now I am not saying this is entirely England’s fault (although we seem to be the only nation to have as body as self-centred as PGMO), anymore than it is the fault of referees on the Continent, but this is how it is. Football has become fractured – we might all be playing to the same set of rules but the interpretation of those rules in Europe is different from place to place.
But so self-centred have the English become (perhaps on the basis that “we invented the game” and so “we are the only people who know what the rules should mean”) that the game in England is drifting further and further away from the game in Europe.
And this might be considered an ok thing, except for the fact that the referees in international games are by and large not English, and so don’t follow our approach.
The fact that this issue has not been resolved, or even contemplated, is a indictment of Uefa and Fifa, so maybe while we are at it, we could get rid of them, along with PGMO, and simply start again.
.
