Which teams have been the best and which the most successful

By Nitram

WHICH TEAMS HAVE BEEN THE BEST, AND WHICH TEAMS HAVE BEEN THE MOST SUCCESFUL DURING THE PREMIERSHIP YEARS

Well the first thing to try and clarify is what is the difference between the ‘best’ and the most ‘successful’?

Well broadly speaking I have classified the ‘best’ as a reflection of how many points points a team has acquired over the Premier League years, and who has the highest average seasonal finishes. Where as I feel ‘success’ per se, is how many trophies a club has won, because that seems to be the mainstream medias sole definition of ‘success’. Trophies.

This is just about the Premier League and as such will not include Europe. I just wanted to see how clubs had performed in the Premier League since it’s inception back in season 1992-1993

I have only looked at the top 5 clubs as they are so far ahead of anyone else as to make it pointless looking beyond them. Therefor the following is the numbers for Arsenal, Man Utd, Liverpool, Man City and Chelsea.

So, the first thin we will look at is the ‘BEST’ team.

I have done this in 2 parts. The first shows the numbers up to and including last weekend’s matches. 

Team Goals For  Against  Pts
Man U 2427 1290 1137 2622
Arsenal 2351 1286 1065 2500
Liverpool 2145 1339 1006 2420
Chelsa 2229 1346 883 2382
Man City 2018 1225 793 1979

 

So, they are just the crude numbers for each statistic bringing us totally up to date. 

The next table though is up to the end of last season. The 34th Premier League season. I have done this because it makes it easier to do some averages. This gives us a much better insight into how each club compares on a season by season basis. Therefor all the numbers here are the average per season.

Team For Against  Diff Points Position
Man Utd 70.9 37.4 33.5 76.8 3.00
Arsenal 68.7 37.6 31.1 73.5 3.02
Liverpool 68.5 39.0 29.5 70.6 4.23
Chelsea 65.0 39.1 25.8 69.5 5.00
Man City 68.8 41.7 27.1 67.5 6.66

 

So, what conclusions can we draw from these statistics. This is what I see. You may see something different.

1: How incredibly close Arsenal are to Manchester United. Our average finishing position per season over 34 years is just 0.02 below them, and that is soon to change.  Arsenal only have to finish 3 places above Manchester United this season to move us up into first place on average finishes over what will then be the premier Leagues 35 year history.

That will make Arsenal the BEST team in Premier league history, finishing position wise. Although it is likely Man Utd will still be around 100 points in total or just under 3 per season, ahead of us. making them still the BEST points-wise. 

2:  Despite regularly being told how boring and negative we are, over the years we have actually scored more goals than the ever entertaining Liverpool. 

3:  We only score 2 goals less per season than Man Utd

4: Man United have actually had the best deffence over the 34 years, letting in 0.2 of a goal less than Arsenal per season.

5:  Despite their illegal doping both Man City and Chelsea lag well behind both Manchester United and Arsenal when it comes to consistency of performance over the 34 years.

Now heres the rub. How does being potentially the BEST team in the Premier Leagues history relate to being the most SUCCESFUL?  Itt has to be said, not very well. The following is a table of domestic trophies.

Note: This table I have split into two. Basically, and not to put too finer point on it, “Non-cheats” and “Cheats”. I do this because in both Chelsea’s and Man City’s case, nearly all (In Citys case all in fact) have been won in what I would term as the ‘doping’ years. Yes, I know what they were doing wasn’t always classed as ‘illegal’, but it was still ‘doping’ and without it those 2 teams would almost certainly not be in the conversation. In fact, Man City, especially, would possibly not even be in the Premier League given their propensity to visit the lower tiers of English football on a fairly regular basis. 

But, alas the doping happened and the trophies arrived, all bought and paid for. So here are the tables, warts and all.

In what follows, PL = Premier Leagues FAC = FA cups LC = League Cups (In it’s many guisses) CS = Community/Charity Shield. I have put these in brackets in the total as many don’t like to count them. I’m on the fence to be fair.

Non-Cheats

Team: PL – FAC – LC – CS = Total (Incl. CS)

Team Premier League FA Cup League Cup Community Shield Total (inc CS)
Man Utd 13 6 5 11 24 (35)
Arsenal 4 9 1 10 14 (24)
Liverpool 2 3 6 3 11 (14)

 

Again what does this tell us? This is what I take from it:

1: Given how remakably close we are to Man United in the BEST analysis, it is remarkable how far we are behind them in the Trophies. In fact, as I pointed out above we are soon to go above them in the BEST table on finishing positions. So, how can we be so far behind them on trophies, especially in the titles won?

For better or worse, this is my take on it. Pesonally I think it’s down to a combination of things. Firstly the arrival of Abramovic followed by the arrival of the Mansours.

Secondly the building of the Emirates Stadium. Their arrival couldn’t of happened at a worst time. We were at our most vulnerable. It caused us to go10 years with a zero nett spend. negligible gross spend, at a time when Man City, Chelsea and Man United were spending vast amounts on players, AND assets stripping us. Without that, and even with the building of the Emirates, I believe we would have possibly won two more Premierships and maybe Man Utd two fewer over that 10 year period.

That would of brought us to 11 v 6: still a sizable gap but not so bad. And then when you consider Arteta would have already had two more Premierships if the cheats that are Man City were not fielding a team built on illicit earnings; bringing us two more titles closer to Man Utd on 11 v 8.

In fact, really not so bad at all considering they are one of, if not the biggest and wealthiest clubs in the world, who would be even richer if it wasn’t for their greedy owners. 

And that is why I think it is Arsenal, above anybody else, that was affected the most by the financial doping, legal and illegal, of both Man City and Chelsea.

But hey, it is what it is and we still finish above Liverpool in the ‘LEGAL’ trophies table, which I bet will be a surprise to most given how the two clubs are portrayed in the media.

Team PL FAC LC CS Total (inc CS)
Man City 8 4 7 4 19 (23)
Chelsea 5 7 4 3 16 (19)

 

Now, what conclusions can we draw from that?   It pays to cheat is what immediately springs to mind.

Some conclusions:

Overall, what I think this shows is that Arsenal are a massive, very successful football club. We would be even bigger if Chelsea and Man City had been required to grow organically, rather than via mega investment from billionaire owners, a lot of which was illegal.

To move to the next level Arsenal MUST win a Champions League. We have been very close twice. Losing once with 10 men, a game we still could easily have won. We were the best team in Europe that season. And losing once after penalties. 

Despite the oil money. Despite the lack of a Champions League. Despite constant media abuse. We have a massive World Wide following. We are a massive club. The potential to grow into one of the biggest clubs in the World, challenging Man Utd, Liverpool, Real Madrid, Barcelona and Bayern Munich is very real, and I think that is what is behind a lot of this hatred we are currently seeing.

The banter club has bitten back and they don’t like it.

Well let them rant. Let them highlight anything that goes our way and ignore things that don’t. We’ve been putting up with it for years and it’s unlikely to stop anytime soon. Crack on. 

Footnote:

Arsenal are clearly not the only club affected by the cheating of Man City and Chelsea, but I do believe we were the most affected for reasons outlined above.

I believe Liverpool would also have won more if not for the cheats. 

Others outside of those I have analysed above may have entered into calculations if it wasn’t for the cheats. Spurs for one, who I have, despite being our sworn enemies, praised many times on here for attempting to do things the ‘right’ way. They too have a right to be outraged by what City especially have done to them.

Either way I have enjoyed putting this together and revealing just what a force we are in the Premier League, despite the challenges we’ve faced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *