- If the Premier League gets bad refereeing, that is its own fault
- Which teams have been the best and which the most successful
By Tony Attwood
If you have been reading my ramblings for a while you will know that Fifa is far from being my favourite organisation. Like all monopolies that are self-controlling it has become self-seeking, passing rules and regulations that have as much to do with benefitting itself as they do with benefiting football at large.
For decades clubs have put up with the self-appointed bunch of a self-serving elite in Fifa, Uefa and the like dictating what happens in football, but now, finally, after years of waiting and pleading, he Union of European Clubs has submitted a formal complaint about the way football is run.
Unfortunately for Europe it is not the complaint Europe wanted for it is in essence a complaint of the rest of the world against Europe and the way it dominates football. For European football is seen as the elite. The countries win the competitions, and clubs from Europe dominate world football and Uefa and its clubs more or less keep the power.
Within European football itself there is an elite group of clubs logically named European Football Clubs which has getting on for 1000 members, and quite simply it sees itself as the dominant body in European and hence world football. So it wants to create a new group for the elite, called World Football Clubs, which in turn would push aside the country-representing bodies like Uefa and Fifa.
In short, the clubs do the work, the clubs take the financial risk, the clubs pay the players (even when they are injured) and so the big clubs want their view represented, heard and taken full note of, just as players, leagues and countries are already represented. The Union of European Clubs already exists, it is argued, so this can be expanded to a world so why not a world wide body in this regard. Clubs have issues they all find they have to fight, so why not?
And indeed I would certainly sympathise with this aim – and indeed often have. as when countries come along, pick the best players from clubs, play them in internationals, return them injured and simply say “get him ready for next time.”
The only concern among some is that it is obvious where the power lies – and that is with the very big clubs in Europe such as Real Madrid, PSG, Bayern Munich and the like. And I don’t immediately add Arsenal to the list because the biggest of the big clubs are the ones who play in leagues that have become so weakened by the big club dominance, that the same club wins the league most of the time. Manchester City if they were now not being hauled through the courts, would be a natural fit. I am not sure Arsenal is at all of this sort of dominating mindset.
The new organisation, it is claimed, would organise better tournaments using different formats. And they seem to have the traditional organisers worried, because in effect the big power in football does already exist with these clubs that have come to dominate their own countries by winning the league every year.
So the issue has gone to the European Commission challenging the current arrangement. What is demanded is a body representing the leading football clubs who employ most of the players who get selected for internationals, and for that body to run and control such competition as the Champions League.
Now of course in all such arguments there is more than simply a statement that says “we want to be in control” because in effect everyone wants to be in control. So what the clubs have rather cleverly presented is a Memorandum of Understanding, which is being used to push through the changes, breaks the EU rules on anti-competitive behaviour.
Now this is always a difficult position for sports, because for any national or international event to take place (such as the World Cup) there has to be just one competition which itself then says that those participating in its competition, can’t join a rival competition. The argument is that otherwise there would be two rival world cups.
But the EFC (European Football Clubs) is recognised by both UEFA and FIFA as the sole independent body for clubs in Europe. And this new move effectively challenges that position. As clubs have expressed an interest in the new competition the EFC has allegedly been telling the clubs that they simply cannot join any new organisation.
The problem with such a stance is that if effectively stops progress and the evolution of new organisations, which is one of the fundamentals of democracies and of progress.
Sport has long seen as “different” in terms of EU rules but this seems to have allowed sporting bodies to become authoritarian, refusing to allow discussion for change. So the UEC is suggesting the way football is run is not compatible with EU law. In effect clubs should be free to join in other competitions.
It is an important issue within football because it asks the question whether the elite clubs should have the power to decide who plays in the top competitions. Where that happens, it is argued, there is no open competition at all.
Now this complaint against Fifa has been expanded, as for example with allegations that Fifa has not taken the environmental initiatives it has signed up to seriously. Thus, the complainants say, Fifa is not a body to be trusted and so should not have any engagement with a new competition.
And Fifa are on dodgy ground here as it has a long running agreement with Aramco, the corporation that holds the world’s largest crude oil reserves, and the largest daily level of oil production in the world. Thus the argument is being advanced that Aramco is being used to obstruct rather than further climate action, and Fifa is complicit in this. Meanwhile the UN is using Cop31 in Turkey to gather information from athletes on way the climate crisis is affecting their sport. It is a story that is going to run and run, and could soon dominate all sports news.
