Why buy an English football club when most clubs lose money? Here’s the answer

 

 

By Tony Attwood

It is an issue that has puzzled and fascinated me in equal measure for years.  Why, if you have lots and lots of money, might you buy an English football club when most football clubs in England lose money?  Of course if it is a club you support, it might be a way of saving your club from extinction, but otherwise…. I am not sure.  Or at least I have not been sure until recently.

I think I now understand, not least through studying the way Arsenal’s finances are working.  For as it turns out, the club has just turned the corner into profit, after years of loss-making.  And here and in the next article, I will try and explain what’s happened, and what makes me feel positive about the financial future of the club I support.

Of course I am not directly involved in any of this: I have nothing remotely like the money to buy even a bit of a club, but I did spend some time as an academic before moving into business, and my business made a profit, so I think I have a spot of insight. 

So I started by asking, “Why spend a fortune buying a loss-making club?” Clearly there is some arrogance there, (as in “They don’t know what they’re doing, but I do”), and a fair amount of ignorance.  But there is a way of taking a football club into profit – and the good news is, Arsenal are on exactly the right track.

Arsenal is a particularly interesting case here in that it has lost money for quite a few years running, and has been constantly supported by the owners.   Then, when recently the club announced that it was making a number of people redundant, there was an outcry from the supporters’ associations.  No one seemed to have offered words of thanks to the owners for keeping the loss making club running, and keeping these people in jobs for all this time.

But why was Arsenal losing money?   Not every club loses money, and not all of them lose money all the time, but some seem to.  So what’s going on?

Before I retired I was chair of a plc – not a company remotely the size of premier league club but still a plc which meant we had to follow the rules pertaining to plcs, and take steps as needed to drive us toward profit.  So I write with a little bit of knowledge of these matters and I can say, to simplify everything, that losing money is fine if two factors are in place.  One is that the corporation owners have enough money to ensure that staff, suppliers and everyone else you owe money to, can be paid.  The other is that you have a viable plan that is leading the company back into profit.   And not just a one-off profit, but profit, year by year.

Now if you study Arsenal’s accounts you will see that although they have had year after year of losses those losses have been coming down.   To give just a couple of examples in round figures, in 2023 the loss was £52.1m.  In 2024 Arsenal lost £17.5m.  Last season it was just over £1m loss, so things are moving in the right direction.

This is the step by step approach that most large companies go through.   A period of reform and development can be a loss making period, which is ok if the owners are indeed investing for the future.

To go back a bit to 2022/3 Arsenal’s pre-tax loss increased from £45m to £52m, despite football revenue rising £96m 26% from £369m to a new club record £465m.  The reason for that was that compared with earlier seasons the profit from player sales halved from £22m to £11m and the costs of running the ground went up from from £432m to £521m.

The fact is that most clubs seek to live through their own means (which is to say, not Manchester City).  But if clubs want to succeed they have to accommodate ever higher payments to players (as we have just seen with the new salary agreed with Declan Rice.)

To pay for this the club needs not to finish in the top four each season, and do very well in the Champions League, while continuing to develop star players through its youth system.  At the same time the club needs to bring in young players who might develop into stars, rather than relying on spending fortunes on transfers of established players from elsewhere.   

Where it goes wrong is through buying players at high cost from other clubs and then finding a) the players aren’t good enough and need to be sold at a loss and b) the hoped for long run in the Champions League and to a lesser extent the FA Cup doesn’t happen. 

A drop down the league, removing subsequent Champions League ventures can thus be a disaster – as the likes of Tottenham Hotspur and Nottingham Forest must be finding.   Worse, attempting to put matters right by changing managers, sometimes several times a season, costs a lot of money in compensation, gives t he club a bad name, and generally speaking doesn’t work.  Arsenal, you will have noticed, like to keep their managers for years, only going through the jettisoning procedure where ludicrous sums of money have been wasted.

Thus while there were some who demanded the removal of Arteta after a couple of eighth place finishes, and even after a couple of second place finishes (for not having a “winning mentality”) the club ignored such calls, as those running the financial side of the club were delighted to see the losses reducing.  Likewise while others objected to redundancies and price increases, the fact is these were needed in order to take the club into profit.

This article is continued in the next piece…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *