- Media don’t know what to except with Kepa, but they know how to make a fuss
- The really destructive approach to football by a few clubs might be coming to an end
by Tony Attwood
What follows is my personal understanding of the case between Manchester City and the rest of the League. But I would stress I have no legal training, and this is a personal understanding. If I have made any errors herein in terms of fact and they are reported to me with sources, I will of course apologise and correct my account.
Any sanctions by the Premier League or FA for Manchester City could have to wait until into next season, or even later, according to some sources. There is an assumption that the appeal put in by the club against the current sanctions is likely to fail, but they will then refuse to accept any punishment and at least two more hearings are planned expected if their appeal fails.
Of course none of this is officially confirmed by anyone, so it is just me trying to gather information, but the club has seemingly been involved in taking matters fairly slowly, so the assumption looks reasonable. Talk Sport are suggesting a couple of months could pass before anything else happens, but they have tended towards a lenient interpretation of the situation throughout. At the moment we don’t know.
In fact the attitude emerging seems to be that although the club were found guilty of every charge save one brought by the league, that counts for nothing; that was (it has been suggested) a passing legal shot to get the thing moving. Which seems a bit strange to me, if a club is breaking the rules, but I am absolutely not a solicitor or barrister. I’m just trying to follow a complicated legal case.
The idea that the club has inflated their revenues to cover the real input from their sponsors by £900 million is also being dismissed with a metaphorical shrug, suggesting that the figure is simply invented for the purpose of the initial interrogation. But maybe no one really knows how much money is invovled, or maybe the records are missing!
Of course none of this is being said in public, and none of it can be traced back to any individual, but the thought that things are being deliberately slowed down is backed up by fact that there simply hasn’t been any progress on the case against ManC since the club were found guilty of 114 of the 115 charges brought against them.
Certainly an appeal has been launched and its hearing is set to take place next month, although any possible sanctions are expected to be handed down to City in 2027 if their appeals are unsuccessful, according to TalkSport.
Meanwhile, the club claim to have a ‘comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence’ that supports them in their case. At the same time, some Premier League clubs have asked for sanctions to be applied this season (again according to TalkSport) but, as some of their interviewed guests have pointed out, this is not guaranteed as there has been no sanction hearings with the independent commission or anyone else. In short things are moving very slowly and no one is quite sure how things will proceed.
So the time table could be a hearing in December and then an appeal on that in January as we aren’t yet anywhere near the end what with legal arguments, barrister summaries and reports, and so on. And all the while no one is quite sure what the rules say, because there has never been a case like this before! And indeed because of that whatever the outcome there could be more appeals!
So some people are saying we are going to be lucky to get a decision on the case this season! And there then could be another appeal under a rather obscure set of Rules called Rule X arbitration which I won’t claim to understand. I repeat I am not a lawer!
That could take another month or so – more if they can’t agree a suitable date, and then… well at that point, again no one really seems to know. If City lose as most people seem to expect there will then be a penalty imposed, and of course they can appeal that, so this could go on into 2028. Meanwhile the club is doing what it threatened to do – which is taking the case through every level of legal process knowing that all the way through the rest of the Premier League is having to pay its own costs, with little chance of ever getting them all back. The Times has reported indeed that the Premier League have asked clubs to “provide legal protection for chief executive Richard Masters and four other board directors should City sue them.”
And that of course could be a concern because I do recall the club threatening to sue the League if the League took action against them – although I admit at this moment I can’t find a copy of that from the newspapers, so maybe my recollection is wrong.
But either way this is a shocking mess for football, and the one thing we can say is that it is not doing much for Manchester City’s reputation either, beyond its current support. If these cases do go ahead and it is reported how much the League, and thus in effect the other clubs, are paying for all this, I imagine there will be a turn of opinion completely against Manchester City, which I doubt they will ever be able to overcome. I mean how would you feel if Arsenal can’t buy player X because the money they were going to use has all going on the case against Manchester City?
