- Arsenal v Newcastle: our regular ref who waves yellow at Arsenal – and the implications
- Arsenal v Newcastle; home and away and the possible final table
By Tony Attwood
The BBC open their build-up report with the news that “Newcastle have beaten Arsenal three times this season – once in the league and in both legs of the EFL Cup semi-finals. No side has ever defeated the Gunners four times in a single campaign.” They then rub it all in by telling us that Arsenal haven’t won in the last five league and cup games, haven’t won in their last four home games, but have “only lost their final home league game of the season once in the past 27 seasons, winning 22 and drawing four.”
So maybe there is hope after all.
This will be the 197th game between Arsenal and Newcastle United with Arsenal winning 85, which is just over 43% and Newcastle at just under 37% with 72 wins.
However since May 2022 the results have not been of the best from Arsenal’s point of view, with two victories, one draw and five defeats – the last two of these being in the League Cup earlier this year. The one decent victory Arsenal have managed was the 4-1 home win on 24 February last year. Havertz, Saka and Kiwior got the goals, along with an own goal to add to the fun.
The referee is Simon Hooper. His record this season is 47.8% of his games are home wins, 26.1% are away wins and a similar 26.1% were draws. He is not the most pro-home-team referee however, as John Brooks sees over two thirds of his games as home wins, while at the other extreme, referee Robert Jones sees only 19% of his games as home wins.
Meanwhile Anthony Taylor has overseen an astonishing 30 league games this season and half of them have been away wins! Yet again we see that which referee the club gets has a major impact on the results.
So if the referee follows his normal pattern of behaviour we should be ok. If however someone at PGMO has told him to “balance his figures” before the end of the season, every decision could be going against us.
Meanwhile, on a different matter I should add that although, as we have seen, Newcastle have been doing very well of late, standing at the moment fourth in the league table for the last six games, if we consider the last six games broken down by home and away form we see the gap between today’s two teams has shrunk and is now slightly in Arsenal’s favour.
Pos | Team | P | W | D | L | F | A | GD | Pts |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
11 | Arsenal home | 6 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 7 | 7 | 0 | 8 |
13 | Newcastle away | 6 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 6 | 11 | -5 | 7 |
Now we must admit that since winning the League Cup on 16 March, Newcastle (according to their stats) have been doing rather well. But a look at who they played tells as different tale, for their victories have been against Brentford, Leicester City, Manchester United, Crystal Palace, Ipswich Town and Chelsea.
Of those teams, two have been relegated, one was distracted by the forthcoming FA Cup final, one has the most hopeless financial issues and the other was Chelsea who have lost four and drawn one of their last six away games. In essence, none of these teams have been putting on much of a show against Newcastle, who have had just about the easiest ride possible of late in terms of league games.
In terms of injuries, Newcastle have four players ruled out: Lewis Hall, Joelinton Apolinario de Lira, Matt Targett and Kieran Trippier. On the doubtful list are Sven Botman who seems unlikely to make it and Joe Willock who has a 50/50 chance of playing.
Injured for Arsenal are Gabriel Jesus, Takehiro Tomiyasu, Gabriel, and Merino. Rated 50/50 are Declan Rice and Gabriel Martinelli. There is talk of a return for Kai Havertz – the report reads, “‘He’s done certain parts of the sessions in the last two days and looks in great shape, but I think it’s more of a shout for all the medical staff and the doctor, especially, to give the clearance. Then it’s how Kai actually feels to contribute if he’s required.”
The media however are not impressed. MSN offer us as their line up
Raya;
White, Saliba, Kiwior, Lewis-Skelly;
Odegaard, Partey, Rice;
Saka, Trossard, Martinelli
The Metro, who for reasons known only to themselves always print their line ups upside down offer (when turned around) exactly the same. As indeed do the Standard.
My view, for what it is worth, is that no one will be risked but the strong team will be put out in the hope of a win, so that various returnees, and maybe a few youngsters can get some time on the pitch in the last match away to relegated Southampton. (Southampton are playing Everton at noon today).
A win today would make for a very relaxed final game, with the chance to play any returnees who are fit, and maybe one or two youngsters.
Thought Newcastle had the rub of the green with a lot of the referees decisions , against 12 again .
Tough start.
Newcastle are a very good team, and a bit of a bogey team for us, so a win is very satisfying.
They came out flying, and it was only thanks to some more remarkable saves from our number 1 that we stayed in the game. He is some keeper. We gradually got in to it and were easily the better team in the 2nd half.
Over the whole piece we just about, just about deserved to win a very tight match against a very good team.
As for the ref. Thought he was okay until the last knockings when he let a few, what I thought were obvious fouls go. I’ve seen worse. We still should get better.
Steve, I agree, especially in the last 10 minutes and during the 5 +++++++ ! added minutes. (why was so much time added, if not to give Newcastle a chance to score?)
First half of the first half was difficult and Raya was brilliant. Second half a different story and we were completely on top – so it was a shame that we had to finish on the defensive against their 12 men.
All our players were good, with special mention for Kiwior. I don’t know whether Saliba was injured, but, contrary to commentators’ expectations, Calafiore was in complete charge in our defence. I will be sorry if Tierney leaves, but it was good to see him come on for his Emirates farewell, – same for Jorginho. Pleased to see Gabriel, Merino and Jesus in the lap of honour and the new home strip looks good.
Altogether a good result against a very strong opponent.
Steve Vallins,
I didn’t think he was terrible, both sides were holding, pushing etc. However, there was no stoppage time at the half and I can’t remember the last time, but ok. Hooper never stopped the game, regardless of which players were on the turf. There was one goal in the 2nd half so with the exception of one minute for that, where did the other 4 minutes of 5 added came from?
After the 5 minutes there were several obvious times to blow the whistle but Hooper didn’t. It seemed like he’d let them play until Newcastle scored. Even on 98 minutes it went to a VAR review to end the match. Over 98 minutes before the officials would allow an Arsenal win.Not a good look for the officials and the League. Just before Mikel Arteta was given a yellow (and touch line ban) for kicking the ball away, Burn threw the ball at, and hit, Gabriel Martinelli who was on the ground after a harsh tackle by Burn. No Yellow. His throwing a ball at an opponent is a Yellow Card. It is also delaying the restart; 2nd Yellow Card and therefore automatic Red Card. Ask Trossard. Trust that Hooper knew Arteta needed one more Yellow for a 1 game ban. He obliged.
Also, what about denying a goal-scoring opportunity, as per the Newcastle sub’s first action in wrestling Martinelli to the ground, Only a yellow, but much much worse than the Saliba event (away at Bournemouth?) where VAR callled successfully for the yellow to be upgraded to a red card.
Another addition to the body of evidence which confirms that PGMOL treat Arsenal more harshly than other teams.