- There’s a shortage of league tables just at the moment. I can’t think why
- Top of the league, and they didn’t get a shot on target
So once again we see a controversial red card issue (and yes I am talking about Dowman’s Card Tuesday night – though it could well be Foden being sent off in the recent Manc derby)
Now there are several point I want to make – but must say the card didn’t decide the game- we were awful but that is all I will say as the below points are more important
So first Arteta’s reaction and the press backlash.
Arteta supposedly said “get into the changing room Max” . Quite clearly the right thing – sometimes you seem to see red carded players adjourn to the bench (Something they are not entitled to do) – making sure Dowman was out of sight and mind for his benefit the better.
Next Arteta stressed the pre-match talks on discipline – clearly Fleetwood had little to lose making it a physical game and any Arsenal player reacting was going to let us down. In a cup game with little respite. So Max did let us down and the tough love issued was absolutely correct for the night the team and the future of the young player.
Now the most major point.
So at least two incidents this year of a dangerous tackle provoking a response where the response has been punished, rather that the provocation.
So let’s just remind ourselves of the definition of serious fowl play
“A player exceeds the necessary use of force and/or endangers the safety of an opponent. This includes lunging with excessive force from any direction, two-footed challenges, or making full, high-intensity contact with studs showing onto the shin or ankle.”
If anyone is to argue that Neal Harrison didn’t tackle from behind, didn’t make stud contact, didn’t follow through so hard as to scissor trap Dowman’s legs making the stud contact more serious then you must have been watching a different game to me. The several commentators that said Harrison got the ball need to read the laws, it was irrelevant, the excessive force meant it was serious fowl play and should of been punished.
The game is once again getting itself into a serious dilemma with this easy branding of red cards. (If anyone in the street defends themselves or react to an attack, who is wrong and who should get nicked?)
Let us just remind ourselves where the need to red card violent tackles came from. Eduardo (career ending), Diaby (career ending) and Ramsey (Major rehabilitation) all were the drivers behind the red card rule.
Now we have turned full circle. Two tackles to provoke red card response. Such an easy option to take out best players.
To the nasty bunch who will use such a tackle – You know what you are.
To the players who get lynched – please start lining up your law suits – the FA is not applying a duty of care or fair stance.
We are clearly back awaiting another career ending tackle or legal action to bring the FA to reason.
Nick the Gooner

Marttin Taylor was sent off for the tackle on Eduardo.
Nitram you’ve always stated in football every decision is subjective , red or yellow card , has he taken too long with that throw , do I award a corner for how long the keeper holds the ball ..
This is an area where players have problems with referees where 1 week it’s ok the next it’s not .
Yesterday the 2 worse tackles happened in the first 10 minutes of the game by the same Liverpooh player , the first one was down the back of Odegaard’s Achilles ( Sky commentary it wasn’t malicious just badly timed ) no action taken by the referee not even a chat . Then not long after the first tackle he did the same to Tzolis , down his Achilles , again no action taken by the referee . Now the first one could quiet easily been a straight red card on its own and then do the same again doesn’t make sense , the first yellow in the game was for a pull back . So now we get this referee taking no action on nasty tackles but couldn’t wait to get a card out for a pull .
Getting back to the Sky commentary how can anyone state whether a tackle is mistimed or malicious the outcome could be exactly the same a badly injured player
Steve vallins
Just to say, and by no means wishing to be disrespectful to this article, I did not write it.
I have presented an article to Tony which I hope will go up soon, but somehow there has been a mix up of Authership with this one.
Re, your obsevations on the 2 early tackles I couldn’t agree more. Both in my opinion could of been a red, particularly considering only on Saturday a similar, nay identical challenge was a red.
Definately both yellows.
Yep, flashing cards for kicking the ball away 2 metres is fine. Challanges that endanger a player, such as the 2 yesterday and on Dowman don’t even warrent a second look it seems.
MOTD were all over the shirt pull but didn’t even show those two early fouls, despite their ‘Live commentator’ (typed on their web page in real time) saying both were definite yellows.
So, a deliberate editorial decision by the BBC to show Liverpool as the victims, and Arsenal as the ones ‘getting away with it’!!
Last paragraph couldn’t agree more .
Just think 80 minutes with 10 men , don’t even get to a shirt pull .
Last paragraph couldn’t agree more .
Just think 80 minutes with 10 men , don’t even get to a shirt pull .