Match Review: Anthony Taylor – Arsenal Vs Queens Park Rangers (1 – 0) [27/10/2012]

Posted on by WalterBroeckx

Match Review: Anthony Taylor – Arsenal Vs Queens Park Rangers (1 – 0) [27/10/2012]

If you are new to this site and this is your first visit then please: Read this to fully understand our reviews.

Today’s referee is Anthony Taylor

MATCH REVIEW DETAILS – Anthony Taylor (2012-10-27)
Period 1
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
0 THROW IN QPR C Armand Traore concedes a throw in. 1
0 THROW IN QPR C Armand Traore concedes a throw in. 1
0 THROW IN QPR C Armand Traore concedes a throw in. 1
1 FOUL QPR C Junior Hoilett Commits a Regular foul. 1
1 FREE KICK ARS C Aaron Ramsey takes a direct free kick. 1
1 THROW IN QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a throw in. 1
2 FOUL ARS C Mikel Arteta Commits a Handball foul. 1
2 FREE KICK QPR C Armand Traore takes a direct free kick. 1
4 GOAL KICK QPR C José Bosingwa concedes a goal kick. 1
4 GOAL KICK ARS C Jack Wilshere concedes a goal kick. 1
6 THROW IN ARS C Lukas Podolski concedes a throw in. 1
7 THROW IN QPR C José Bosingwa concedes a throw in. 1
7 THROW IN QPR C José Bosingwa concedes a throw in. 1
7 NOTHING QPR C handball but Arsenal could continue their attack 1
7 ADVANTAGE ARS C Arsenal could continue the attack on the flank 3
8 THROW IN QPR C Samba Diakité concedes a throw in. 1
9 THROW IN QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a throw in. 1
10 GOAL KICK ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a goal kick. 1
10 FOUL QPR C Esteban Granero Commits a Regular foul. 1
10 FREE KICK ARS C Jack Wilshere takes a direct free kick. 1
11 THROW IN QPR C Armand Traore concedes a throw in. 1
12 GOAL KICK ARS C Lukas Podolski concedes a goal kick. 1
12 THROW IN QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a throw in. 1
13 FOUL ARS C Aaron Ramsey Commits a Regular foul. 1
13 FREE KICK QPR C Stéphane Mbia takes a direct free kick. 1
16 THROW IN ARS C Bacary Sagna concedes a throw in. 1
16 THROW IN QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a throw in. 1
19 THROW IN ARS C André Clarindo dos Santos concedes a throw in. 1
19 FOUL ARS C Mikel Arteta Commits a Regular foul. 1
20 FREE KICK QPR C Esteban Granero takes a direct free kick. 1
20 THROW IN ARS C Vito Mannone concedes a throw in. 1
20 THROW IN QPR C Junior Hoilett concedes a throw in. 1
21 THROW IN ARS C Thomas Vermaelen concedes a throw in. 1
21 OFFSIDE QPR C Bobby Zamora is played offside by Thomas Vermaelen from a ball by Adel Taarabt 1
23 GOAL KICK QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a goal kick. 1
24 FOUL QPR ARS NC Push not given 3
24 FREE KICK ARS NC For the foul on Wilshere 3
24 THROW IN ARS C André Clarindo dos Santos concedes a throw in. 1
25 THROW IN ARS C André Clarindo dos Santos concedes a throw in. 1
25 FOUL ARS C Lukas Podolski Commits a Regular foul. 1
25 FREE KICK QPR C 1
25 OFFSIDE QPR C Ryan Nelsen is played offside by Per Mertesacker from a ball by Esteban Granero 1
26 THROW IN QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a throw in. 1
28 THROW IN ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a throw in. 1
28 THROW IN QPR C Armand Traore concedes a throw in. 1
30 FOUL QPR C Bobby Zamora Commits a Regular foul. 1
30 FREE KICK ARS C Thomas Vermaelen takes a direct free kick. 1
31 FOUL ARS NC Bacary Sagna clearly stops the ball and that made the QPR player fall over. 3
31 FREE KICK QPR NC It was no foul so should have been no free kick 3
32 FOUL ARS C Aaron Ramsey Commits a Regular foul. 1
33 FREE KICK QPR C Ryan Nelsen takes a direct free kick. 1
33 FOUL QPR ARS NC Taraabt barges in the back of Wilshere, not given 3
33 FREE KICK ARS NC 3
34 THROW IN QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a throw in. 1
34 THROW IN QPR C Junior Hoilett concedes a throw in. 1
34 FOUL QPR C Samba Diakité Commits a Regular foul. 1
35 FOUL QPR NC Wall is only 6 meter away when Podolski strikes the ball. The wall just ran forward before the ball was kicked. Should have been retaken 3
35 FREE KICK ARS C Lukas Podolski takes a direct free kick. 1
35 FREE KICK ARS NC Free kick should have been retaken 3
36 THROW IN QPR C Samba Diakité concedes a throw in. 1
38 THROW IN ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a throw in. 1
38 CORNER ARS C Thomas Vermaelen concedes a corner kick. 1
41 THROW IN ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a throw in. 1
42 OFFSIDE QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips is played offside by Per Mertesacker from a ball by Esteban Granero 1
42 FOUL QPR C Samba Diakité Commits a Regular foul. 1
43 FREE KICK ARS C Mikel Arteta takes a direct free kick. 1
44 FOUL ARS C Santiago Cazorla Commits a Regular foul. 1
45 FREE KICK QPR C 1
45 THROW IN ARS C Per Mertesacker concedes a throw in. 1
46 THROW IN QPR C Adel Taarabt concedes a throw in. 1
Period 2
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
45 THROW IN QPR C Bobby Zamora concedes a throw in. 1
46 OFFSIDE ARS C Olivier Giroud is played offside by Ryan Nelsen from a ball by Bacary Sagna 1
46 FOUL QPR ARS NC Granero catches Wilshere late on the ankle, ref gives nothing 3
46 YELLOW QPR NC Studs on the ankle and late 3
46 FREE KICK ARS NC 3
48 THROW IN QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a throw in. 1
48 GOAL KICK ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a goal kick. 1
48 OFFSIDE QPR C Junior Hoilett is played offside by André Clarindo dos Santos from a ball by Esteban Granero 1
49 FOUL QPR C Esteban Granero Commits a Regular foul. 1
50 FREE KICK ARS C Mikel Arteta takes a direct free kick. 1
50 OFFSIDE QPR C Bobby Zamora is played offside by Bacary Sagna from a ball by Junior Hoilett 1
52 FOUL ARS C Mikel Arteta Commits a Regular foul. 1
52 FREE KICK QPR C José Bosingwa takes a direct free kick. 1
53 GOAL KICK QPR C Shaun Wright-Phillips concedes a goal kick. 1
53 OFFSIDE QPR C Junior Hoilett is played offside by André Clarindo dos Santos from a ball by Esteban Granero 1
53 FOUL ARS C Olivier Giroud Commits a Regular foul. 1
54 FREE KICK QPR C Ryan Nelsen takes a direct free kick. 1
54 THROW IN QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a throw in. 1
55 FOUL QPR C Esteban Granero Commits a Regular foul. 1
56 FREE KICK ARS C Santiago Cazorla takes a direct free kick. 1
57 FOUL QPR C Esteban Granero Commits a Regular foul. 1
57 2ND YELLOW QPR NC The foul was already close enough to a yellow card but the following dissent surely should have earned him a yellow card and his dismissal. 4
59 FREE KICK ARS C Olivier Giroud takes a direct free kick. 1
59 FOUL ARS C Olivier Giroud Commits a Regular foul. 1
59 YELLOW ARS C Olivier Giroud recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. 1
61 FREE KICK QPR C 1
61 THROW IN QPR C José Bosingwa concedes a throw in. 1
62 GOAL KICK ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a goal kick. 1
63 FOUL ARS C Bacary Sagna Commits a Handball foul. 1
63 FREE KICK QPR C Esteban Granero takes a direct free kick. 1
66 THROW IN ARS C Jack Wilshere concedes a throw in. 1
66 FOUL ARS ARS C 3
66 ADVANTAGE ARS C Possible chance to start an attack 3
67 THROW IN ARS C Aaron Ramsey concedes a throw in. 1
67 THROW IN QPR C Samba Diakité concedes a throw in. 1
68 GOAL KICK ARS C Mikel Arteta concedes a goal kick. 1
70 THROW IN ARS C Lukas Podolski concedes a throw in. 1
72 GOAL KICK QPR C Armand Traore concedes a goal kick. 1
72 OFFSIDE QPR C Djibril Cissé is played offside by Per Mertesacker from a ball by Adel Taarabt 1
75 GOAL KICK QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a goal kick. 1
76 THROW IN QPR C Samba Diakité concedes a throw in. 1
77 GOAL KICK QPR C Stéphane Mbia concedes a goal kick. 1
77 CORNER QPR C José Bosingwa concedes a corner kick. 1
78 FOUL ARS C Thomas Vermaelen Commits a Regular foul. People could argue it was shoulder to shoulder but it looked shoulder against the back. 1
78 RED QPR C Stéphane Mbia recieves a RedCard for the following reason: Fight. 1
79 FREE KICK QPR C Julio César takes a direct free kick. 1
80 CORNER QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a corner kick. 1
81 GOAL KICK ARS NC Ryan Nelsen didn’t seem to touch the ball anymore 1
81 CORNER QPR NC Ryan Nelsen didn’t seem to touch the ball anymore 2
82 GOAL KICK ARS C Olivier Giroud concedes a goal kick. 1
83 GOAL ARS NC Mikel Arteta was offside when the ball came from Ramsey to him. With a lot of players between the assistants points of view and the collission Ramsey/defender it will have been impossible to spot. And the assistant gave advantage to the attacker probably as is stipulated in the instructions 5
83 OFFSIDE ARS NC Mikel Arteta was offside when the ball came from Ramsey to him. With a lot of players between the assistants points of view and the collission Ramsey/defender it will have been impossible to spot. And the assistant gave advantage to the attacker probably as is stipulated in the instructions 2
84 FOUL ARS C Andrey Arshavin Commits a Regular foul. 1
84 FREE KICK QPR C José Bosingwa takes a direct free kick. 1
86 YELLOW QPR C Adel Taarabt recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Dissent. 1
86 THROW IN QPR C Adel Taarabt concedes a throw in. 1
86 THROW IN QPR C Nedum Onuoha concedes a throw in. 1
86 CORNER QPR C Julio César concedes a corner kick. 1
87 CORNER QPR C Ryan Nelsen concedes a corner kick. 1
88 FOUL ARS C Mikel Arteta Commits a Regular foul. 1
89 FREE KICK QPR C José Bosingwa takes a direct free kick. 1
90 GOAL KICK QPR C Esteban Granero concedes a goal kick. 1
90 THROW IN ARS C Mikel Arteta concedes a throw in. 1
91 GOAL KICK ARS C Andrey Arshavin concedes a goal kick. 1
92 THROW IN ARS C André Clarindo dos Santos concedes a throw in. 1
92 FOUL ARS C Bacary Sagna Commits a Regular foul. 1
92 FREE KICK QPR C Esteban Granero takes a direct free kick. 1
93 CORNER ARS C Vito Mannone concedes a corner kick. 1
93 FOUL QPR ARS NC Clearly pulled him back to win the ball, not given 3
93 FREE KICK ARS NC For the very clear foul on Cazorla 3
93 FOUL QPR C Samba Diakité Commits a Regular foul. 1
94 FREE KICK ARS C Vito Mannone takes a direct free kick. 1
94 FOUL ARS C Aaron Ramsey Commits a Regular foul. 1
94 FREE KICK QPR C José Bosingwa takes a direct free kick. 1

Let us have a look at his competence numbers in this game

COMPETENCY SUMMARY – Anthony Taylor (2012-10-27)
Period 1 Called Total Correct %
ADVANTAGE 1 1 100.00
CORNER 1 1 100.00
FOUL 11 15 73.33
FREE KICK 11 15 73.33
GOAL KICK 5 5 100.00
NOTHING 1 1 100.00
OFFSIDE 3 3 100.00
THROW IN 29 29 100.00
TOTAL 62 70 88.57
WEIGHTED 64 88 72.73
Period 2 Called Total Correct %
2ND YELLOW 0 1 0.00
ADVANTAGE 1 1 100.00
CORNER 5 6 83.33
FOUL 14 16 87.50
FREE KICK 13 15 86.67
GOAL 0 1 0.00
GOAL KICK 10 11 90.91
OFFSIDE 5 6 83.33
RED 1 1 100.00
THROW IN 13 13 100.00
YELLOW 2 3 66.67
TOTAL 64 74 86.49
WEIGHTED 68 97 70.10
Totals Called Total Correct %
2ND YELLOW 0 1 0.00
ADVANTAGE 2 2 100.00
CORNER 6 7 85.71
FOUL 25 31 80.65
FREE KICK 24 30 80.00
GOAL 0 1 0.00
GOAL KICK 15 16 93.75
NOTHING 1 1 100.00
OFFSIDE 8 9 88.89
RED 1 1 100.00
THROW IN 42 42 100.00
YELLOW 2 3 66.67
TOTAL 126 144 87.50
WEIGHTED 132 185 71.35

Let us see if it evens out in this game and have a look at the bias numbers

BIAS SUMMARY – Anthony Taylor (2012-10-27)
Period 1 Arsenal % Queens Park Rangers % Total
Correct For 34 55.74 27 44.26 61
Correct For Weighted 36 57.14 27 42.86 63
Incorrect Against 8 100.00 0 0.00 8
Incorrect Against Weighted 24 100.00 0 0.00 24
Fouls Commited 7 46.67 8 53.33 15
Fouls Penalised 6 85.71 5 62.50 11
Period 2 Arsenal % Queens Park Rangers % Total
Correct For 32 50.00 32 50.00 64
Correct For Weighted 34 50.00 34 50.00 68
Incorrect Against 6 60.00 4 40.00 10
Incorrect Against Weighted 19 65.52 10 34.48 29
Fouls Commited 10 62.50 6 37.50 16
Fouls Penalised 10 100.00 4 66.67 14
Totals Arsenal % Queens Park Rangers % Total
Correct For 66 52.80 59 47.20 125
Correct For Weighted 70 53.44 61 46.56 131
Incorrect Against 14 77.78 4 22.22 18
Incorrect Against Weighted 43 81.13 10 18.87 53
Fouls Commited 17 54.84 14 45.16 31
Fouls Penalised 16 94.12 9 64.29 25

Please leave a comment!

——————————–

The books…

The sites…

Recent Posts

4 Replies to “Match Review: Anthony Taylor – Arsenal Vs Queens Park Rangers (1 – 0) [27/10/2012]”

  1. A not that convincing performance from the ref in general.
    The foul spotting was a weak point in the first half. That improved a bit in the second half but still rather too many missed clear fouls.

    He let Granero off the hook in this game. On 3 occasions he should have been given a yellow card. He only got one. The red card was okay. What was Mbia thinking at that moment? Kicking at an opponent without the ball even near is always a red card.

    The goal was offside from Arteta. The ball came of Ramsey could be seen in the replay but it was not clear from the first moment as the QPR player kicked the ball and that came on the leg of Ramsey. But with the ball then moving forward Arteta was offside.

    With a few players between the touch of the ball from Ramsey and the assistant on the far side it will have been almost impossible for the assistant to see who moved the ball to Arteta.
    The instructions are that in case of doubt you give the decision to the attacker. The assistant did this I think. But it was an offside and should have been ruled out.

    If there would have been a review system the goal probably would have been cancelled.

  2. Looks like again we got the disadvantages from the referee allowing blatant fouling.
    Fair enough, the goal was offside.
    But I’m a fan – I’m still glad we got it!

  3. I had a feeling, during this game that the ref was leaning towards QPR. This report has not disabused me of the idea! The offside goal was not his direct responsibility but allowing a mobile fouling machine to roam the pitch for 97 minutes was! Excellent report and thanks.

  4. I don’t agree with the direction that the scoring system is going; there are never any NC worth only 1 point. Certainly important decisions should be weighted more heavily (such as goals, red cards), but when it is a simple no call on a foul and then you make it a 3 point decision by saying ‘should have been a yellow card’ then you skew the end percentages.

    I wouldn’t say that this is inherently unfair, because they are your reviews and you can score them how you want, but if you are going to continue to use the line “they say above 90% of the calls are correct and we show otherwise”, then you should say that using a simple x/total calls were correct to get your percentage. More and more it appears that a ref will get 95% of the decision right, but every incorrect call is weighted so heavily that you end up giving him a 75% correctness rate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *