Arsenal News

Live Arsenal News

Arsenal latest news

Arsenal News & Transfers
As featured on NewsNow: Arsenal newsArsenal News 24/7

Arsenal News, Only Arsenal, Blogs, Transfer News


August 2021

West Bromwich Albion and the referees. Do the errors even out in the end?

By Walter Broeckx

This article is part of the series of the Referee Review 2013. You can find links to earlier articles on the bottom of this article.


In this part of the series we have a look at each team and see how the bias panned out for each team. This is based on the decisions themselves without putting any weight on different types of decision. A total table will be published at the end of this and then you can compare each team with the other teams. At the end it will be an interesting table, I can assure you that.

We will show this in a table for each team highlighting each type of decision. We will show you the totals when the team in the article got a favourable decision and when they got it against them.

As you know the traditional mantra “it all evens out at the end of the season” should be visible here. So we are just trying to see if it really does all even out.

As noted, there is no weighting of the decisions in the table.  For now we just take each decision at the same value, which is of course not at all saying that a wrong penalty call not  more important than a wrong throw in decision.  But we have to start with the basic figures.

But now let us move to the next team in our survey:  West Bromwich Albion.

We did 22 games of WBA last season and this is 57,89% of their total games. I think a good number of games to see how things went for them.

west bromwich albion

Watch Arsenal Live Streams With

In the second column we see the type of decision. And in the column “favoured” we see how many decisions favoured WBA when we reviewed them. And in the column “Penalised” we see how many times a wrong decision went against them.  The total swing is the difference between the favoured decisions and the penalised decisions.

A negative number in this column means that the total was against WBA and a positive number means that the total decisions was in their favour.

In the last column we see the average swing per game. And this gives an indication on how many decisions went against a team or were in favour of a team. The lower the number the lower number of decisions that were wrong. And a positive number indicates that in each game they get some decisions in their favour and a negative indicates how many decisions the team has to overcome.

The total number of decisions going in their favour was 16 decisions. Less than one decision per game. But the good thing for them is that it is a positive swing. If you can recall last year’s results we found that they had a rather negative bias against them. But not this time around.   It can’t be so but it looks as if refs wanted to make up for last season a bit.

On the more important decisions we see that they had 5 wrong goals in total in the games we reviewed. Three in their favour and two against them. So a positive bias in the goals section of one goal. For the penalties the end result was no bias. But this doesn’t mean of course that some of the decisions might have cost them points or won them points.

So a small positive swing and one could say that on average they benefit for one decision per game.  For WBA it almost does even out in the end.

Recent posts

Arsenal Anniversaries: 10 August

The books…

The sites from the same team…


4 comments to West Bromwich Albion and the referees. Do the errors even out in the end?

  • nicky

    Five incorrect goals in 22 games seems very high to me. Regardless of whether the mistakes even out, to have nearly 23% affecting the most important aspect of games, namely, GOALS, reflects badly on match officials.

  • Mark Bennett

    Someone feeling guilty about blatant cheating to win last seasons game?
    Could get a diving board in at the training ground if you sign Saurez as well

  • Kevin

    This site is so far wide of the mark. You can rant on and on about all the ifs and buts until your blue in the face. Bottom line is the best teams finish at the top and the poorest teams finish at the bottom. We have manager who was great and has many attributes but only a fool would not question the current path he is following. The squad is not good enough to compete against the best hence when we play the best Europe wide we come up short. We are told we have money now but here we are a week away from the season and we have no improvement. This is what you should be concerned of instead of rattling on about immaterial dross and start to be honest about our present position. As a season ticket holder and long time arsenal fan it’s so sad and frustrating to have a manager and board that seem to have lost their desire to compete.

  • Stuart

    To be honest there are plenty of articles on this site and on others so maybe you could go and discuss the things you request there. This article is about the referee reviews hence the theme of the article being, well, about the referee reviews.