31 responses

  1. Menace
    28/03/2015

    Yes. Charge them for use of both data & intellectual property rights. These ‘free press’ thieving bar stewards are quick to grab your money so don’t think twice about getting some funds from them. I am sure there are several good football causes that can benefit.

  2. nicky
    28/03/2015

    In my learning days during the last century, when all of us in the School First XI copied the hairstyle of Arsenal players. (Centre parting a la Ted Drake, Cliff Bastin and Eddie Hapgood), my Gran (who cleans at the Emirates) remarked “Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery”.
    Today, rather than accept money from one of the poorest and misread of newspapers (except for cricket reporting) Walter should just be allowed to bask in the flattery bestowed.

  3. Brickfields Gunners
    28/03/2015

    I would suggest that you prank them with fake stories and facts and figures . When that blows up in their faces , lets see how they try shift the blame !

  4. jambug
    28/03/2015

    It is very well deserved that your persistence and hard work is being recognised, and obviously personally rewarding for yourself, if a little frustrating I would guess, to be plagiarised so often. But as you say:

    “Yes, Untold is being copied by the press, and we are having a bit of an influence on what topics are debated, but there is still one hell of a long way to go”.

    In deed there is, because as much as I would like this statement:

    “The worst time was when only ourselves and about three other web sites were charting referee bias and the papers would not even consider the subject”.

    to be true, I fear it is not.

    A conciliatory nod in the direction of referees ineptitude is a long way from the concession that they are ‘Biased’.

    I think the ‘it all evens out’ mantra would still very much hold sway throughout the Media.

    I cant say I’ve seen ONE article, nay comment, that suggests that referees are anything other than ‘fair’. Crap maybe but biased? NEVER.

    Bias is a massive part of what UA has exposed but I’m afraid the media have not picked up on that at all. Sorry.

  5. Tom
    28/03/2015

    Tony and Walter

    I suppose there’s nothing wrong with a little self promotion. It seems everyone is guilty of doing it these days, but some of the ideas you guys claim credit for ,have been around for a long time.

    When Leo Beenhakker took over the Polish national team job in 2006, one of the first things he said was how difficult it would be to advance into the European elite ,without rebuilding the sorry state of Polish grassroots football, forming academies, and increasing the number of youth coaches.

    In fact , such was the poor state of footballing infrastructure in Poland according to Beenhakker, that he was quoted saying ” some of the pitches Polish proffesional footballers train on are unsuitable for dog walking, for the fear of dog’s dislocating his ankles”

    This , by the way, is something the Dutch have been basing their Europe’s leading youth footballing programs for decades.

    The idea of cautioning the captain for team’s infractions isn’t new either.
    It’s been talked about since at least the 1982 World Cup in Spain, when Zbigniew Boniek, Poland’s best player missed the semifinal game against Italy because of two yellow cards, one of which was issued to him for the wall not moving back the right distance at the free kick.

    Walter should probably remember that one. Boniek scored three goals against his Belgium in the tournament.

    His omission in the game against Italy cost Poland the chance to make it into the final.

    The fact is , most of ideas how to improve football , have been tossed around for a while and claiming ownership or some sort of copy rights violations, is just plain silly.

  6. jambug
    28/03/2015

    The liars back.

  7. finsbury
    28/03/2015

    The disingenious bungling troll is attempting to insinuate that The research by Untold didnt consider that Coaches around the world haven’t thought about coaching kids. Even bough the original article in question on coaching in the UK, as the troll is fully aware, was based upon the per/capita ratio of footballers to coaches being produced in the lowlands. As all are aware the Spanish and German FA’s simply used their football brains to look at the stats.

    The very same type of statistical analysis the troll attempts to ignore in it’s failed efforts to defend the honour and integrity of the PGMO, and we can conclude what a wise “act” that was in light of Riley’s recent comments.

    Blimey. 😉

  8. jambug
    28/03/2015

    Finsbury

    Not worth entering into debate with the troll.

    He’s a confirmed liar who just makes things up when you call him out, and who dismisses everything Untold stands for as the ravings of paranoid fools.

    If your lucky he’ll refuse to talk to you like he has me.

    Wont stop me calling him out for the liar he is though.

  9. bjtgooner
    28/03/2015

    A very good article Tony.

    While plagiarism or copying of UA by the press is annoying, we must understand that that is the modus operandi of the media in all their activities – from sport to politics, current affairs and oh yes – the news.

    When UA is the source of the information sensible stories and suggestions should end up being viewed by a wider audience – unless the press completely distort the original story.

  10. Gord
    28/03/2015

    I think it was Metro, but some medja outlet published an article nominally slagging Szczesny. Something like 78% of Arsenal wants him traded or sold. I didn’t read the article, just the snippet on Google News.

    About the smallest group a person can get 78% from, is 50 (39/50).

    As we are counting, a first guess of Poisson statistics is not out of order. The variance equals the mean, and hence the standard deviation is about 6.2. It is reasonable to find a sample out to about 2 standard deviations, so this sampling could be consistent with population fractions from about 66% to 90%. I don’t know that even 66% of ALL Arsenal supporters want Szczesny to leave.

    It is entirely possible, that the medja person that wrote this, stumbled into a gathering of Le Gnome (or whatever they are called) at a pub. And yes, I can easily see that group as being that heavily against Szczesny, anything to cause Arsenal to fail. But, I wouldn’t describe that sample as being drawn from Arsenal supporters.

  11. finsbury
    28/03/2015

    Jambug,

    It was genuinely genuinely funny that a self-declared expert on physiotherapy attempted to airbrush an entire sector of that industry out of existance in order to contiunue using Untold Arsenal as a platform to attack the clubs highly praised physios (that’s right, the England physios…not just certified or qualified but employed too 😉 ). Why would an internet troll feel the need to constantly lie in order to try and slur the name of Arsenal Football Club I don;t know, but the lies are at least consistent. And poorly constructed too as seen with the above effort to refer to the Dutch coaching system. Truly weird, considering the original article was based on the irrefutable statistics from Dutch Football that all in football have known about for decades.

    Just another poor desperate interent troll with no credibility.

  12. Gord
    28/03/2015

    Youth Players and Development

    I ran across this article, because one of the people mentioned was an Arsenal youth.

    http://www.newstalk.com/reader/47.302/44238/

    My initial thoughts on this, goes back to a recent Supreme Court of Canada ruling (from Winnipeg?) about a parent who leaves a youth at home alone. Apparently now, because of that ruling, no parent in Canada can leave an elementary school (age 12 and under) at home alone. I could see someone easily extending this to a parent sending a similarly aged child to England to learn how to play football on their own.

  13. WalterBroeckx
    28/03/2015

    Ramsey just scored for Wales with a looping header

  14. bjtgooner
    28/03/2015

    Does anyone have any further news on Wellbeck?

  15. Gord
    28/03/2015

    I haven’t seen anything BJT.

    I just finished looking through the BBC babbling up to 60 minutes or so, and Ramsey seems to be having a good game. And it is surprising that the BBC haven’t bashed Arsenal at all.

  16. Gord
    28/03/2015

    Ugggh! From the BBC:

    > 83 Min Israel 0-3 Wales

    > Wales midfielder Aaron Ramsey is down now. Concerns for Wales and Arsenal fans – he’s trying to run off what appears to be a groin problem.

  17. Gord
    28/03/2015

    Why are there so many groin injuries? I used to see lots of groin injuries in broomball (played on ice). But football fields were all quite hard, and everyone wore multistud shoes instead of 6 stud. Is it because of watering the field before play to make the ground soft?

  18. bjtgooner
    28/03/2015

    Ramsey is now off the field, not sure how serious the injury is.

  19. Gord
    28/03/2015

    Hodgson isn’t endearing himself. The national sides take team players, bring them back injured. Well, Hodgson apparently isn’t happy that Wenger is taking his time to get Walcott back into the side. More un-needed pressure.

    Hodgson, break your leg getting off the plane in Italy!

  20. bjtgooner
    28/03/2015

    @Gord

    Agreed, the national managers don’t care a toss about the well being of the players – provided they are available for the national teams they are quite happy to send them back injured, knowing that by the time the next set of internationals turn up the players should have recovered.

    Hodgson is not in a good position to make remarks about Walcott, more than once Walcott’s career has been interrupted by injuries sustained playing for England.

  21. Gord
    28/03/2015

    Getting back to groin injuries, how many players in warmups can do the splits? Either side to side, or front/back?

    TV never shows warmups.

  22. Gord
    28/03/2015

    I grumble about Hogdson doing stupid things with Walcott. And I wish that Hogdson trips on the stairs and breaks his leg.

    In Italy, a player injures his knee in training, and the manager gets death threats.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/32102867

    But in a sense, the same thing happens with Arsenal. Some player gets hurt in a game (or practice), and the neanderthals come out and say that the injury was Wenger’s fault. Yep, I seen it. The player was running past the Arsenal bench, and Wenger ran to the edge of the field with a field hockey stick and broke the leg of one of his own players. Dumb.

  23. Gord
    29/03/2015

    Odd, no message about moderation. Oh well, note was about Zak Ansah in his loan at Plymouth.

  24. Brickfields Gunners
    29/03/2015

    Truly lost somewhere in the translation –

    After all the e-mails and penis lengthening exercises, I think the wife is finally beginning to notice, because I overheard her telling our next door neighbor that I had became an even bigger dick than I ever was. I even recorded it to show guys at the Pub.

  25. Brickfields Gunners
    29/03/2015

    And again…

    This teacher wanted to try something different in the classroom. So she thought she would ask a question to start with that everyone would answer in the same way.
    ‘Who in this class’ she asked ‘thinks they are stupid?’
    One boy at the back of the class stood up.
    The surprised teacher asked the boy why he felt he needed to stand up.
    ‘I didn’t want to leave you standing up all by yourself’ he replied.

  26. Brickfields Gunners
    29/03/2015

    Hard to fool the experts –

    An old farmer got pulled over by a young state trooper for speeding. The trooper, fresh on the job, decided to throw his weight around and started lecturing the farmer about his speed. He did his best to make the farmer feel uncomfortable but eventually got around to writing the ticket. As he wrote, he had to swat at several flies that were buzzing around his head.

    “Having some problems with circle flies there, are ya?” asked the farmer.

    The trooper stopped writing the ticket and looked up. “Well yeah, if that’s what they are,” he said. “I never heard of circle flies, though.”

    “Oh, they’re pretty common on farms,” said the farmer. “We call ’em circle flies because they’re always circling around the back end of a horse.”

    “I see,” said the trooper as he continued writing the ticket. All of a sudden, he stopped and looked up at the farmer. “Hey…wait a minute, are you trying to call me a horse’s ass?”

    “Oh no, officer,” replied the farmer. “I have far too much respect for law enforcement and police officers to even think about calling you a horse’s ass.”

    “Well, that’s a good thing,” said the trooper as he resumed writing the ticket.

    After a long pause, the farmer continued. “Hard to fool them flies, though.”

  27. Brickfields Gunners
    29/03/2015

    Viva la ….

    A Latin American tour guide was addressing a small group of senior citizens and telling them about the country they were visiting. When he asked if they had any questions, one person inquired, “What is the number one sport in this country?”

    “Bullfighting,” the guide replied.

    The same person asked, “Isn’t that revolting?”

    “No,” replied the tour guide. “That’s number two!”

  28. hrishi
    29/03/2015

    Tony,
    A little far fetched, don’t you think? True, Untold does publish a lot of original research- but to accuse the mainstream media of plagiarism- its ‘softer’ version, of course- is a bit of ‘damned if you do, damned if you don’t’. So when the media does not touch a topic of interest, it’s a result of vested interests, anti-Arsenal bias and so on and when they do, they plagiarise. That’s hardly fair.
    Most of the topics you referred to are quite generic in nature and it’s difficult to explicitly point out a link. Particularly, as Tom pointed out, the idea of coaching and grass-root facilities to improve the national game. On the face of it, that hardly looks like a revolutionary idea that can be ‘copyrighted’. It’s definitely an idea that would have been around since the advent of international football.
    Coming to the issue of refereeing decisions, the fact that it has come into the limelight of late has got more to do with the more ‘glaring’ mistakes this season as compared to previous seasons. Most articles follow one of two ways- ‘it all evens out in the end’ and ‘we need to look at the issue seriously’- with a select few doing a delicate balancing act. That Untold’s view matches with some other sports writer’s view is entirely plausible. Added to that, the unique feature of Untold’s articles contain detailed review of decisions in games and that is hardly seen in the mainstream media. So, unless the Telegraph uses stats from Untold’s ref reviews, the issue of copying does not arise.
    The referee harassing issue was covered in detail almost immediately by (almost) everyone. Again, not an issue that can easily be traced to a specific root.

    Your blog is tremendously popular and it is entirely plausible that a few of those writers may have come across your articles- but so are a lot of other blogs which touch upon these issues. So unless you meant this entire article in jest, I will have to disagree.

  29. Cyrano de Gunnero
    29/03/2015

    Alright, first time post on my favorite webblog.

    Now and then I see disingenuous posts like hrishi’s or Tom’s that makes me ask, can this person read, or are they just trying to oppose a position? Where did Tony specifically use the word plagiarism, or copyright. More like the lack of thoroughness, general band-wagonism, is what Tony’s long running press reviews are about. I don’t bother with mainstream sports journalism, as it makes me feel quite foolish after reading or listening to what some sports expert has to say. I am hardly alone in this. The points made and repeated by Tony and Walter being very open source, begs the questions, why do salaried journalists not raise these points and bang the drum until it breaks? Why no detailed research with numbers.

    To Hrishi’s point: ‘That Untold’s view matches with some other sports writer’s view is entirely plausible. Added to that, the unique feature of Untold’s articles contain detailed review of decisions in games and that is hardly seen in the mainstream media. So, unless the Telegraph uses stats from Untold’s ref reviews, the issue of copying does not arise.’ Two things: this is a webblog, and one with an ironic take on issues, and always with a sense of jest. Other thing, are you a sports writer yourself?

  30. hrishi
    30/03/2015

    @ Cyrano
    I know that Tony did not use the word ‘plagiarism’. That is precisely why I qualified it by adding ‘a softer version’. Just wanted to point out that it is entirely plausible that these issues had a different root. Of course, my entire point was moot IF it was meant in jest- something that I mentioned. If it wasn’t, just take my comment to be an ironic take on the article- nothing disingenuous about it. On the contrary, I have great respect for the work done here- it just doesn’t have to mean I always agree.
    And no, not a sports writer at all!- I apologise if THAT was a rhetorical question!!

  31. Cyrano de Gunnero
    30/03/2015

    well played!

Back to top