28 responses

  1. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    Sorry to go straight off topic but we really are in trouble with VAR if it sees fit to overturn Victor Lindelöf’s Red card.

    This is from the Mail on Sunday on line:

    VAR made the right call to reverse Victor Lindelof’s red card…

    a) The player was in control and technology prevails

    I ask: How are you in control in a slide?

    b) The VAR system was used to analyse a red card awarded to Victor Lindelof

    c) Lindelof appeared to slide through Wolves striker Diogo Jota at Molineux.

    I ask: “Appeared to slide” NO he did slide !

    d) Referee Martin Atkinson at first look believed the player was out of control.

    Isay: As much as I dislike Atkinson he was spot on. There was absolutely no way Lindelof was in control. If you are sliding, or in a ‘skid’ for want of a better word, how the f*** are you in control. You cant pull out. You cannot avoid going through the player.

    e) VAR correctly deemed the tackle was merely reckless, and was due a yellow.

    MERELY reckless ! WTF ?

    To me it was:

    -Pre meditated. (If he didn’tget the ball he sure as hellwas going to get the man.)

    -Late.

    -Out of control. (He wassliding FFS)

    -Wreckless. (He knew exactly what he was doing)

    -And it certainly endangered the players well being.(It was so bad that it was one of those that makes you instinctively draw breath and look away.)

    The bottom line is it was a terrible challenge.

    As I, and others have said on here many times, VAR is simply going to be used to reinforce the bias that already exists.

    How was Lindelofs tackle in anymore ‘control’ than Lucas Torreira’s tackle against spurs, and that was looked at again and deemed worthy of a red card.

    I may be wrong, and the Untold lads may put me right, but if that wasn’t a red card challange then we really are in trouble.

    Reply

    • TomP
      20/03/2019

      In other words your opinion differs from those on VAR duty

      Reply

  2. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    By the way, thanks for taking time out to put an article up for us Tony.

    Just like to say I hope you are having a great time.

    Reply

  3. Laos gooner
    17/03/2019

    to add to Nitram’s comments that is the second time in a manchs cheatster match VAR has been used when there has not been a clear and obvious mistake by the ref. The handball at Paris S.G. was not a clear mistake, the red card yesterday was not a mistake. It raises serious questions about the neutrality of the unknown persons in control. Thankfully we do not have VAR unless we reach the final of the Europa Thimble which may give us time to save money for any bribe required by the unseen man of mystery who overrules the official on the pitch at critical moments. That said I bet Swansea would have welcomed VAR. A dodgy falling over by Raheem floor polisher Sterling and an offside goal from Aguero decided the tie, both could be called clear and obvious errors but thankfully for the incompetent gentleman in black it was not in use.

    Reply

  4. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    Laos gooner

    “…….there has not been a clear and obvious mistake by the ref”

    Thanks for reminding me. I forgot to even mention that and that is indeed a massive part of why this is so worrying.

    Because when Torreira’s red card was up for appeal I knew it would fail.

    Not because it was Arsenal but because it was not ‘a clear and obvious mistake’, although being as it was us added to my certainty.

    But the point is, even though I think it was a little harsh as he went for the ball (no excuse in itself though), got the ball (no excuse in itself though), and was unlucky the way his studs ended up ‘high’ because of the way his foot rolled over the ball(a possible excuse).

    But I can see why a red was given, and it was not ‘a clear and obvious mistake’.

    As for yesterdays Lindelof’s red card, even if you some how think it wasn’t a red card there is absolutely no way it can be called ‘a clear and obvious mistake’.

    Really really worrying that a decision like that can be turned over.

    God help Arsenal when it does come in.

    Reply

  5. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    One last thing.

    If it was a clear and obvious mistake why did it take a dozen replays to make the decision.

    Surely by it’s nature ‘clear and obvious’ should take just a quick look because it’s, well…….’clear and obvious’.

    This, clearly and obviously wasn’t ‘clear and obvious’ if you see what I mean.

    Reply

  6. Steve Vallins
    17/03/2019

    @ Nitram
    What worries me with the Lindelofs challenge yesterday was that I thought it looked terrible in slow-mo and not much better in real time and if you are now allowed to go through the man to get the ball we’re in trouble because it’s too selective .
    Last night Keown didn’t think it was a sending off , then when it went to VAR he changed his mind because of the slow-mo replay , then agreed with VAR when the decision was changed to a yellow card , refereeing is now in more trouble than it was before

    Reply

  7. Gord
    17/03/2019

    To rephrase Nitram’s statement.

    If you are driving on a low friction surface (like ice or mud) and your tires start to skid, you have “gone ballistic”. Your path is more or less determined by the laws of ballistics and whatever objects you happen to collide with.

    To slide on the ground is a similar situation. It is only similar, in that the person voluntarily gave up the ability to control their path.

    Is it only reckless to go into a situation in which you will likely collide with someone at speed, and no control over your path?

    Reply

  8. Les Williams
    17/03/2019

    I believe as all you do VAR is just going to be used to confirm bias – makes the “respect” campaigns a complete farce doesn’t it!!!

    I have very little hope for its use in either UEFA or EPL games. I watch La Liga and Bundesliga. The best system I have seen so far has been La Liga – they are quick and correct!!!

    Keown is another of the blinkered idiots of the game – we have lots of them

    Reply

  9. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    Steve Vallins

    “…..if you are now allowed to go through the man to get the ball we’re in trouble because it’s too selective.”

    Agree 100%

    Gord

    “Is it only reckless to go into a situation in which you will likely collide with someone at speed, and no control over your path?”

    As you are intimating, no of course it isn’t ONLY reckless, it is clearly ‘out of control’.

    Les Williams

    “Keown is another of the blinkered idiots of the game”

    Exactly.

    I was embarrased listening to him last night. You could tell the commentator really didn’t agree with him at all but was effectively put in a position where he either had a row with Keown, or tactfully back down. He chose the latter.

    Tragicly and unbelievably his views were backed up by VAR, and now ex referee Chris Foy this morning.

    Quite simply I cant believe what I’m hearing from these so called ‘proffesionals’.

    Shocking.

    Reply

  10. Gord
    17/03/2019

    OT: Humour

    In the news, is a story about a game in Adelaide being held up, because there was a snake on the field.

    Said snake was neither a politician or official, it was a brown snake.

    I guess it took about 8 minutes to remove the snake.

    Reply

  11. Tony Justin (Eastern Nigeria)
    17/03/2019

    On Arsenal and Napoli, i agree with you Tony. I want to add that it’s not going to be a high scoring encounter hence defensive awareness need to be high. In some of their matches in their league, Napoli don’t score early, I hope this will work to Arsenal’s advantage. All English final awaits… Good luck to the Arsenal.
    Gunners for life! Better days ahead…

    Reply

  12. goonersince72
    17/03/2019

    Tony,
    Hope you’re enjoying Australia. Absolutely lovely place.

    Re AFC v Napoli , on current form Arsenal seem a good bet. The tie should be tightly contested. The team has acquired a bit of defensive nous (Mustafi aside) and I can see Arsenal progressing on away goals. If AFC progress to and win the Europa League they qualify for next season’s CL competition. Ironically, if they win the Europa competition and (as is very likely) finish in the top 4 places in the EPL the automatic bid will go to one of the sodden bastards we’re battling with now, I believe. I suppose it’s a nice ‘problem’ to have. As it says on the badge….”Forward”!

    As you have pointed out numerous times in these pages, referee bias is obvious, ‘control’ from on high is obvious and the Cheaters have their favs. Anyone recall those darlings of Leicester City a few seasons ago? One-dimensional Vardy dove his way to 10 PK’s that season FFS. We accept the bias is real. It persists because of the ‘hiding in plain sight’ reason Untold has pointed out for years; LACK OF TRANSPARENCY AND LACK OF ACCOUNTABILITY. Unless this changes everything remains the same. The FA, the PGMO, EPL and their tools in the Media are all corrupt. Somehow, someway the beautiful game needs to wrested from their greasy grip. I can’t write anymore, the blood pressure medication beckons. COYG!

    Reply

  13. goonersince72
    17/03/2019

    Correction;
    “needs to be wrested”

    Reply

  14. Gord
    17/03/2019

    Drat, Liverpool won. Milner converts a penalty in the 81 minute. Congratulations Craig Pawson on the win!

    Game is nearly over, and Everton leading Chel$ea. Giroud was recently subbed on. Please don’t score Giroud! 🙂

    Reply

  15. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    It’s finished Everton 2 – 0 Chelsea

    Nice.

    Reply

  16. Gord
    17/03/2019

    Congratulations to Atletico Madrid! Their women’s team just set an attendance record of 60,739!

    https://sportstar.thehindu.com/football/atletico-madrid-vs-barcelona-crowd-attendance/article26561357.ece

    Reply

  17. Gord
    17/03/2019

    Ospina suffered a head injury in Napoli’s game today, and has been taken to hospital.

    I hope he’s okay.

    Reply

  18. Nitram
    17/03/2019

    Gord

    Sad to hear.

    Lets hope he’s okay.

    Reply

  19. John L
    17/03/2019

    Best wishes to Ospina for a full recovery.

    Reply

  20. Menace
    17/03/2019

    The one tackle that has not been mentioned is the studs on to Lenos midriff. It was a red card offence but was ignored by all and sundry after the official gave a yellow.

    Reply

  21. GoingGoingGooner
    17/03/2019

    Lindelof’s tackle was horrible. I think his sliding knee took out the Wolves’ player’s standing leg AND because it was his knee and attached leg that took him out, the player did a complete flip

    Reply

  22. GoingGoingGooner
    17/03/2019

    I hope someone in the press notices the writhing, flipping, contortionist-like dive that the Mane perpetrated against Fulham, today.

    Reply

  23. goonersince72
    17/03/2019

    GoingGoingGooner @10:14pm

    Not going to happen. I refer you to the last paragraph of my post on this thread @3:56pm.

    Reply

  24. Samuel Akinsola Adebosin
    18/03/2019

    Hmmm. Okay. In as much as the overall result of the 2 legged Europa League Cup quarterfinal match that will decide the fates of Arsenal or Napoli to further participate in this season’s Europa League Cup competition could look on paper too close to call. But notwithstanding and be it as it may be, let us Gooners not entertain any doubts in our minds as to whether Arsenal will knock out Napoli or not over the course of playing the 2 legged quarterfinal match that’ll take place soon between the duo club sides. For, definitely, Arsenal will knock out Napoli. And this my claim is not just a claim for the sake of it because of my having a great passion for Arsenal. But it’s a true claim by me that has bone out of my instincts as I’ve said in one of my comment posting before that, my instincts have instinctively informed me that Arsenal will beat Napoli 4-0 at the Emirates Stadium during the 1st leg match of the 2 legged match tie to take control of the tie and be in control of the 2 legged quarterfinal match. And therefore be in unassailable position in terms of the number of goals scored over the course of playing at home and away by both clubs. Therefore for Napoli, this unassailability in aggregate number of goals scored that will be to the favour of Arsenal absolutely will consequently see Napoli get knocked out from the competition this season.

    Reply

  25. Gord
    18/03/2019

    I don’t know anything about about a Mane dive. It is suspicious that Liverpool was handed the win by a penalty.

    That there is an explanation for how the PGMO gave the win to Liverpool!!!!!!!!!! is wonderful.

    Reply

  26. Brickfields Gunners
    18/03/2019

    I guess that it is the various directors’ mandate to squeeze out the drama till finally the fat lady sings. It would be boring for all if the EPL was decided all too early. Or became all too predictable.

    A few ‘unexpected’ twists and turns will always ensure that the spotlight be on the EPL -the greatest football league in the world .

    Liverpool appearing to getting caught up with at the home straight by City ; with Chelsea and Man. Utd losing ground and steam , and Arsenal with another mini revivals .

    And Spurs . Well Spurs will always be Spurs.And probably will implode this season as well . And the Arsenal fans may yet get to sing about them , that it happened again ! Have missed it the last two years !

    And the Wolves . Probably everyone’s second team ,especially when it be may hoped to be rewarded by a favour from them if they beat a direct opponent .

    Reply

  27. Josif
    18/03/2019

    @Brickfield

    Sorry, mate, but Wolves are not my second team as long as they are Jorge Mendes FC.

    But I did enjoy their beatings of Spuds, Chavs and Scums.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop