Untold Ref Review: Wigan 0 – Arsenal 4

Posted on by WalterBroeckx


Follow us on Twitter @Untold Arsenal

———————————-

“Making the Arsenal” – is available on Amazon, Arsenal on line, the Woolwich Arsenal site and in the Arsenal store.

———————————–

By Ref Reviewer 02

For the game between Wigan and Arsenal we had ref Clattenburg in the middle between the two teams. Was he the man in the centre?

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight
7 Foul Santos Sammon N/C Ref misses a nudge 0 0
9 Foul Koscielny Moses C 1 1
15 Foul Figoura Ramsey C 1 1
17 Foul Arteta McCarthy C 1 1
18 Foul Figoura Ramsey N/C Clean tackle winning ball.no contact with man 0 0
22 Offside Sammon N/C Kos was playing him on 0 0
23 Foul Caldwell RVP C was a 50/50 but going with ref 1 1
27 Goal Arteta C 1 3
28 Goal Verminator C 1 3
30 Foul Figoura RVP C 1 1
34 Foul Arteta Moses C 1 1
37 Foul McCarthy Ramsey C 1 1
37 Foul Song McCarthy N/C McCarthy wraps his legs around Songs ankles as he wins ball 0 0
39 Offside Gervinhio C 1 1
41 Foul Song Jones C 1 1
42 Foul Walcott Jones C 1 1
Half time 12 16
CORRECT 75,00% 84,21%
YELLOW
RED
PENALTY
GOAL 2 2 100,00
OTHER
Total 2 2 100,00
OFFSIDE 1 2 50,00
Second half
49 Foul RVP Figoura N/C Ref has a good view but allows RVP to impede Figoura 0 0
49 Pen Figoura Ramsey N/C Having missed the foul by RVP, Ramsey is brought down for a penalty, two wrongs making a right. 0 0
51 Foul Caldwell Ramsey C 1 1
51 yellow Caldwell C 1 2
53 Foul Arteta Gomez C 1 1
56 Foul Song McCarthy N/C All Song did was stand there 0 0
56 Yellow Song N/C It was not a foul never mind a booking 0 0
60 Goal Gervinhio C 1 3
62 Other C Good advantage played allowing Arsenal territorial gain 1 1
63 Other C Again a good advantage played after a foul on song, RVP wastes a chance 1 1
66 Handball Moses C 1 1
69 Foul RVP Figoura N/C Ref misses as RVP lays ball off then runs into Figoura pushing him in face, could have been a yellow 0 0
72 Foul Gohouri Walcott N/C Right in front of ref, he gives nothing, sees Theo down then plays a mysterious advantage, poor reffing, Arsenal kick the ball out, what advantage!! 0 0
72 yellow Gohouri C Yet somehow he gives Gohouri a card for a challenge he did not see and a foul he did not give, but it was right decision 1 2
75 Foul Vermaelen ? C 1 1
75 Foul Song ? N/C Ref misses a block challenge by Song 0 0
77 Penalty Song Stam C Big shout from Wigan for a pen but Stam was looking for it 1 3
77 Goal RVP C Arsenal break and score, good Reffing 1 3
83 Foul Arteta Diame C 1 1
84 Foul Coquelin Crusat C 1 1
84 yellow Coquelin C Reckless 1 2
87 Foul Diame Ramsey C 1 1
87 Yellow Diame C Reckless 1 2
89 Foul Gohouri Arteta N/C missed by Ref right on touchline 0 0
89 Foul Santos McCarthur C 1 1
90 Foul McCarthy Coquelin N/C jumps right into him, Ref gives nothing 0 0
91 Offside Gomez C 1 1
2nd half score
TOTAL 18 28
% CORRECT 66,67% 70,00%
YELLOW 4 5 80,00
RED
PENALTY 1 2 50,00
GOAL 2 2 100,00
OTHER 3 6 50,00
Total 10 15 66,67
OFFSIDE 1 1 100,00
TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL 30 44
% CORRECT 69,77% 74,58%
YELLOW 4 5 80,00
RED 0 0
PENALTY 1 2 50,00
GOAL 4 4 100,00
OTHER 3 6 50,00
Total 12 17 70,59
OFFSIDE 2 3 66,67
Correct calls For Wigan 12 44,44%
For Arsenal 15 55,56%
Total correct calls 27
Wrong calls Against Arsenal 7 53,85%
Against Wigan 6 46,15%
Total 13
Total fouls made by Wigan 10 38,46%
Arsenal 16 61,54%
Total 26
Important W/C against Wigan 1 33,33%
Arsenal 2 66,67%
3

 

Clattenberg is my Favourite Ref, I think when he is good he is very good indeed. His Reffing has an honesty and a consistency that is commendable.

Like us all he has bad days at the office, but it is easy to see that his mistakes are genuine and that he really tries to be balanced and fair. At Wigan he missed more than he usually does, he will be pleased that did not affect the outcome.

He played some very good advantages, and a big call correctly led to Theos run and RVP scoring. Not his best day, but he will be pleased with the outcome. Although the decision to book Song was a stinker!!

Also take a look at the wrong calls that almost even out between both teams! One of the rare occasions this has happened with Arsenal this season.

———————————–

—————————————-

Recent Posts

7 Replies to “Untold Ref Review: Wigan 0 – Arsenal 4”

  1. Clattenburg was interesting tonight
    Clych off and we are still the only invincibles 🙂
    Lets hope for a good result the weekend against city.

  2. It will be an interesting review I think, lots of talking points as far as I have seen

  3. It look walter that City should have had a penalty early on.
    Lots of yellow cards for you to review 🙂

  5. @reviewer

    At 56 minutes, you have a yellow for Song that isn’t correct. Why is the weight 0?

    Not having written lately, Happy Birthday Walter.

  6. The first 0 is just for the decision on itself and has a possible score of 0 or 1. Wrong decision / correct decision

    The score of the weight is where we give a certain weight to a decision. For a yellow card the weight is on a possible score of 2. So a correct given yellow card gives the ref 2 (on 2) a wrong given card gives the ref a score of 0 (on 2).

    The “on” column has been left out of the review because we had some difficulties already to get the whole thing on the page.

    the weight scores are
    yellow card on 2 points
    red card on 3 points
    goal on 3 points
    penalty on 3 points

    And thanks Gord 😉

    Never had a better perfect birthday, better said a perfect birthday weekend and even the monday has ended in perfection 😉

  7. Interesting review, it is a shame that yellow cards cannot be appealed as Song has now unfairly accumulated four.

    Regarding tonight’s match, I noted Yaya Toure kicking at Mata when the latter was on the ground and just afterwards having a swipe at him. The ref. did not appear to see these incidents, what are the chances of the FA taking action?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *