Untold ref review : MU 1 – Sunderland 0

Posted on by WalterBroeckx

—————————————–

“Making the Arsenal” – the book of Arsenal’s decline and rebirth

 Untold Arsenal on Twitter @UntoldArsenal

—————————————–

Sign the petition to make sure YOU are not helping fund Tottenham’s new stadium

—————————————–

By Ref Reviewer 02

For the game between Manchester United and Sunderland we had ref Mason in charge.

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight
1 Offside Bendtner C 1 1
4 Offside Chicaritto C 1 1
5 Foul Welbeck Larsson N/C clear foul 0 1
17 Foul Cattermole Fletcher C 1 1
18 Foul Rooney Bendtner C 1 1
18 Yellow Rooney N/C Rooney came in through the air with his trailing leg hitting NB, should have been a caution 0 0
22 Foul Sessegnon Nani C 1 1
24 Foul Jones Sessegnon N/C Jones clearly charges his man into touch without playing the ball 0 0
24 Other N/C Ref gives a goal kick to man Utd 0 0
25 Foul Sessegnon Jones N/C Jones heavy touch allows Sessegnon to nick the ball, Ref gives a free kick 0 0
26 Foul Cattermole Rooney C 1 1
27 Foul Turner Welbeck N/C Ref misses a foul as Welbeck is held 0 0
35 Foul Turner Park C 1 1
36 Foul Brown Chicaritto C 1 1
37 Foul Ji Fletcher C 1
37 Foul Ferdinand Bendtner C 1 1
41 Foul Larsson Evra C 1 1
41 Yellow Larsson N/C The Rooney challenge on 18 was much worse and did not get a yellow 0 0
45 Goal C Brown OG 1 3
47 Foul Ji Ferdinand C 1 1
47 Yellow Ji C An identical challenge to the one by Rooney 1 2
Half time 14 17
CORRECT 60,87% 65,38%
YELLOW 2 3 66,67
RED 0 0
PENALTY 0 0
GOAL 1 1 100,00
OTHER 0 1 0,00
3 5 60,00
OFFSIDE 2 2 100,00
Second half
50 Offside Colback N/C This was apoor decision and could have been decisive 0 0
51 Foul Bardsley Park C 1 1
51 Yellow Bardsley N/C Should have been a caution, was a wild hack at his standing leg 0 2
52 Other N/C From a corner ref misses a deflection and wrongly gives a goal kick 0 0
53 Foul Sund Welbeck N/C Ref misses a foul on Welbeck 0 0
54 Foul Chicaritto Westwood C 1 1
56 Offside Nani C 1 1
57 Foul Sund Chicaritto C 1 1
60 Foul Jones Calback C 1 1
66 Penalty C Assistant indicates a penalty, Ref had a good position and over ruled him 1 3
68 Offside Chicaritto C 1 1
72 Foul Bardsley Nani C 1 1
73 Foul Jones Sund C 1 1
80 Offside Nani C 1 1
87 Foul Meyler Rooney N/C This was a great tackle, hard, feet on the ground, at the ball and fair, but not on Rooney and not at OT 0 1
88 Foul Bendtner Evra C Poor view going with ref 1 1
91 Other Fletcher C Handball 1 1
TOTAL 12 17
% CORRECT 70,59% 85,00%
YELLOW 0 1 0,00
RED 0 0
PENALTY 1 1 100,00
GOAL 0 0
OTHER 1 2 50,00
2 4 50,00
OFFSIDE 3 4 75,00
TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL 26 34
% CORRECT 65,00% 73,91%
YELLOW 2 4 50,00
RED 0 0
PENALTY 1 1
GOAL 1 1 100,00
OTHER 1 3 33,33
5 9 55,56
OFFSIDE 5 6 83,33
Correct calls For Home 17 65,38%
For Away 9 34,62%
Total correct calls 26
Wrong calls Against Home 4 33,33%
Against Away 8 66,67%
Total 12

 

——————————-

Untold Arsenal – the (fairly) complete index

Untold Arsenal on Facebook here

——————————————–

Recent Posts

4 Replies to “Untold ref review : MU 1 – Sunderland 0”

  1. Not always cautioning Rooney when he goes overboard to me is the reason why England will be missing her best player for the next 3 matches at the Euro 2012. Deliberately pampering a player might look good at some point but over time it is going to boomerang as it just did. I believe if Rooney had done what he did in the EPL he would have escaped a booking as the referees would have claimed not to see it. So, a big thank you to the referees of the EPL for putting the whole country in this mess.

  2. I think you’re right about that, @Yommex, and I believe Capello has actually made comments to that effect (although I may have read it on one of those rumor-aggregation sites, so who can know for sure what was actually said).

  3. Yommex, you are right about that

    Letting a player off the hook all the time might be amusing for the player (and his team) in the home league. But it bites you back.

    Maybe if he would have been banned for his elbowing against that Wigan player last year as he should have been then the message would have been clear (if he has enough brains to get any message – but that is another part of the problem maybe). But by letting him escape and getting away with any violent and dangerous thing on a football field you create a kind of mindset in the players mind (where else) and so he considers that he can do what he wants without punishment.

    Until you meat a Fifa/Uefa ref who doesn’t care who you are..

    So maybe the FA and the PGMO have just been both responsible for handicapping the English team in the next European championship.

    Another reason for Gooners who also support England to be angry with those organisations..

  4. Rooney is a prince in england so the refs fear and obey him and infact all man utd staff how many fouls or bookings do they get.the fa should investigate this team before epl is taken to the dogs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *