Untold Ref Review : QPR 2 – Man C 3 – and a novelty

Posted on by WalterBroeckx

By Ref Reviewer 04 and Walter Broeckx

For the clash between QPR and Manchester City we had ref Atkinson in charge at Loftus Road. Read the report from our ref reviewer but also pay attention because in this review we have tried to add something new.

Min Type Foul from On C/NC Comment points weight
3 OTHER Yaya Bothroyd C Trip 1 1
4 OTHER Dzeko Ferdinand C Push 1 1
5 OTHER QPR Dzeko NC Trip 0 0
6 OTHER Young Kolarov C Rash tackle 1 1
9 OTHER Toure Faurlin NC Pull 0 0
13 OTHER Savic Bothroyd NC Tackle didn’t get the ball, got the player nothing given 0 0
21 OTHER Silva Faurlin C Trip 1 1
23 OTHER Savic Helguson C Push 1 1
27 OTHER Barry Gabidon C Push 1 1
27 OTHER Kolarov Bothroyd NC Replay shows Bothroyd tripped himself 0 0
28 GOAL QPR NC QPR scores from the free kick which was wrong given. Goal shouldn’t have happened 0 0
29 OTHER Aguero NC Handball not given by the ref 0 0
32 OTHER QPR Toure C Advantage given – MC almost get a chance from this 1 1
33 OTHER QPR Aguero NC Trip from behind 0 0
33 OFFSIDE QPR C correct decision 1 1
37 OTHER Savic Bothroyd C Jumped in his back 1 1
38 OTHER Barry Bothroyd C Held him to the floor 1 1
40 OTHER Young Aguero C Trip 1 1
43 GOAL MC C correct goal 1 3
Half time 12 14
CORRECT 63,16% 60,87%
YELLOW 0 0
RED 0 0
PENALTY 0 0
GOAL 1 2 50,00
OTHER 1 2 50,00
2 4 50,00
OFFSIDE 1 1 100,00
Second half
46 OTHER Toure Bothroyd C Push 1 1
47 OTHER Aguero Ferdinand C Push 1 1
48 PENALTY Lescot Bothroyd NC Lescott was holding on to the shirt of Bothroyd when he ran to head the ball. His shirt was almost twice his normal size 0 0
50 OFFSIDE MC C 1 1
51 OTHER Traore Richards NC Push 0 0
52 GOAL MC C correct goal 1 3
56 OFFSIDE MC NC Looked level with the defender in the middle 0 0
56 OFFSIDE QPR C assumed correct 1 1
59 OTHER Richards Philips C Trip 1 1
60 OTHER Toure QPR NC Push in the back not given 0 0
64 OTHER Barry Faurlin C Obstruction 1 1
65 OTHER MC? QPR C Trip, advantage given 1 1
68 OTHER MC? QPR NC Push advantage given 0 0
69 GOAL QPR C Correct goal Helguson was not offside when the ball was played in his direction 1 3
69 YELLOW Dzeko NC Came all the way to protest for offside against the assistant. Players going to the assistant like that should be given a yellow card. 0 0
70 OTHER Mackie Kolarov C Push 1 1
72 OTHER Mackie Kolarov C Push 1 1
74 GOAL MC C Correct goal 1 3
76 OTHER Balotelli Gabbidon C Little kick against the ankle 1 1
77 OTHER QPR Dzeko NC Holding him, nothing given 0 0
78 PENALTY Young Balotelli0 C Balotelli goes down with a nice dive the ref was close so could see the dive perfectly 1 3
78 YELLOW Balotelli C Correct to give a yellow for this 1 2
81 OTHER Barton Silva C Goes in from behind and kicks him in the air 1 1
81 YELLOW Barton C A fully deserved yellow card for a brutal tackle 1 2
82 OTHER Milner Philips C Trip 1 1
83 OTHER Dzeko Gabbidon NC Trip nothing given 0 0
92 OTHER Puncheon Balotelli0 C Trip 1 1
2nd half score
TOTAL 19 29
% CORRECT 70,37% 72,50%
YELLOW 2 3 66,67
RED 0 0
PENALTY 1 2 50,00
GOAL 3 3 100,00
OTHER 1 1 100,00
7 9 77,78
OFFSIDE 2 3 66,67
TOTAL SCORE
TOTAL 31 43
% CORRECT 67,39% 68,25%
YELLOW 2 3 66,67
RED 0 0
PENALTY 1 2 50,00
GOAL 4 5 80,00
OTHER 2 3 66,67
9 13 69,23
OFFSIDE 3 4 75,00
Correct calls For QPR 18 58,06%
For MC 13 41,94%
Total correct calls 31
Total Wrong calls Against QPR 8 53,33%
Against MC 7 46,67%
Total 15
Total fouls made by QPR 12 35,29%
MC 22 64,71%
Total 34
ID wrong calls Against QPR 2 40,00%
Against MC 3 60,00%
5
Other wrong calls Against QPR 6 60,00%
Against MC 4 40,00%
10

Some controversy in this game. The first goal from QPR came after a non existing foul. Bothroyd ran away from goal and just stumbled over his own feet and the assistant signaled a foul. QPR scored immediately from the free kick. So a goal that shouldn’t have happened.

In the second half there was an incident when Bothroyd his shirt was pulled when he tried to go for a high ball in the penalty area. This should have been a penalty for QPR.  So one decision going their way, the other not. Speaking about it evens out ….

In this game one could say that the ref despite these errors was very balanced in the way he treated both teams. This can be seen in the wrong calls.

About the novelty  in this review. People who have been following the ref reviews and read the numbers till the end will notice some new numbers. Because I have tried to see how the wrong calls compared in two ways: the average wrong call and the important decision wrong call.

Something we will try to add in the future. If it can be done without adding to much pressure on the ref reviewers.

“Making the Arsenal” – the book of Arsenal’s decline and rebirth

 Untold Arsenal on Twitter @UntoldArsenal

—————————————–

Sign the petition to make sure YOU are not helping fund Tottenham’s new stadium

—————————————–

 

Recent Posts

9 Replies to “Untold Ref Review : QPR 2 – Man C 3 – and a novelty”

  2. nevermind, actually read the last part! So under important decisions you got the yellow/red/goal calls?

  3. Walter: Please correct the formatting.. Its almost impossible to read the whole thing..

  5. Many thanks for ID wrong calls. Some proposals: to show minutes of ID wrong calls in comments. So everyone can see what do you mean by ID wrong calls.

  8. The Norwich v Arsenal ref review should be interesting this week, we’ve got Phil Dowd, and Garratt as lino ;(

  9. Rev04, Walter, Alek,
    KUDOS for initiating the ID wrong calls category (at long last!) – so that “game changers” can be tracked. It is no small thing, as it adds a vital interpretive (qualitative) element that, in the Ref Review context, helps to complement the quantitative assessment. Adding the minutes of what you deem ID wrong calls in parentheses would go the next step in giving readers who care the ability to zero in on the key moments and see for themselves in a time-efficient way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *