The most comprehensive review of referee performance: Match Day #04 with video evidence

Editorial note: No organisation has ever analysed and reviewed the performance of Premier League referees before in this much detail.  As I am sure you can understand, the amount of time it takes our team to complete this work is enormous, but all of us feel this is worth it, for the simple reason that …

Arsenal – Chelsea: 3-0 for a team without a centre forward

By Walter Broeckx A bright start from Arsenal who immediately took the game in hand and went in search for the attack. Chelsea sitting deep as expected and defending numbers from the start. A new manager but nothing changed at first sight. Alexis winning the ball in the Chelsea half and Arsenal pressing Chelsea and …

Arsenal v Chelsea: the teams, the predictions, the fair play league thus far

By Bulldog Drummond When it suits the media and their chums in the aaa they focus on the last match, or maybe the last couple of matches.   But with Arsenal having just won four and drawn two of the last six, and with the two draws being away to last year’s champions of England …

Arsenal v Chelsea, groundhog day, oddball referees, injuries and Mr Africa to buy AFC.

By Bulldog Drummond, If you have been reading the definitive history of Arsenal in the 1930s you will be used to the Arsenal / Chelsea pattern of the era.  Each season Arsenal win the league by beating Chelsea in front of 65,000 and Chelsea just about manage to stay up.  As the story of the …

We need to talk about Granit. Is he DM or box-to-box?

We need to talk about Granit By Tim Charlesworth There is a lot of bizarre hysteria in the Goonersphere at the moment about why Granit Xhaka is not playing (why spend all that money on a bench-warmer etc. etc.).   It makes me wonder what team some people have been watching for the last ten …

Arsenal v Chelsea Sat 24 September 2016 – The Match Officials

by Andrew Crawshaw Before I start on the officials for this coming game I want to raise a point about PENALTIES – as you will have noticed so far this season they are being given which is a major change from the past few seasons.  Last season we were awarded 2 out of 35. This …

How the transformation of Arsenal applies to both the first XI and the back up team

By Tony Attwood This is the team that Arsenal put out last weekend against Hull City. Cech, Bellerin, Mustafi, Koscielny, Monreal, Cazorla, Coquelin, Walcott, Ozil, Iwobi, Alexis. On the beach: Ospina, Holding, Gibbs, Elneny, Xhaka, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Lucas. And the team against Forest Martinez, Maitland-Niles, Holding, Gabriel, Gibbs, Elneny, Xhaka, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Reine-Adelaide, Akpom, Lucas On the …

Like it or not, the video ref is alive and kicking : no stopping it now (I hope)

By Walter Broeckx I have been talking about the video ref for many years now. Tony has given me the chance to  talk about it for many years and on many occasions. I have written articles and showed video clips about the tests that have happened under the guidance of the Dutch football federation KNVB. …

Did top English clubs really up their spending this summer, and how did Arsenal compare to the rest?

By Tony Attwood We have often heard in recent years the stories about how Arsenal is a “selling club” unable to hang on to its youngsters, with the proven child traffickers Barcelona endlessly sniffing around trying to buy back players that they have let go to Arsenal, while using the old “Barca DNA” gibberish as …

Arsenal in the league cup: the referee incidents against Forest with supporting video evidence, plus the draw.

by the Referee review team In the next round we have drawn Reading.  More details on that in a moment, but first following on from the article after our game with PSG in the Champions League, here is a quick review of some of the incidents that occurred in the game against Nottingham Forest (each …

Ref Review: Hull – Arsenal. An extraordinary performance by the referee.

By Usama and Walter HULL CITY vs. ARSENAL COMPETITION: English Premier League MATCH NO. 5 DATE: 17th September 2016 VENUE: KCOM Stadium (Hull, England) MATCH OFFICIALS: REFEREE: Roger East 1st LINESMAN: Darren Cann 2nd LINESMAN: Matthew Wilkes 4th OFFICIAL: Paul Tierney First Half Fouls, Advantages, Cards, and Penalties Time Foul by Foul For Description & …

How the summer spending has affected the league so far, and the missing factor in the analysis.

By Tony Attwood So just how much impact has the mad money spending of this summer had on the Premier League thus far? To try and get an early view onto what all the expenditure has done I’ve created a league table with three extra columns in it. The “Last Year” column shows where the …

Arsène Wenger assaulted by burger as headless chickens take over, and the “618” win through.

A year on, and how the tune has changed.    By Poul Tree. A year ago we met the Tinies in the 3rd round of the League Cup.  Our team was Ospina, Debuchy, Mertesacker, Chambers, Gibbs, Arteta, Flamini, Ramsey, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Campbell, Giroud. This time against Forest the team was Martinez, Maitland-Niles, Holding, Gabriel, Gibbs, Elneny, …

League Cup: Nottingham Forrest – Arsenal 0-4: Xhaka boom again and a brace from Lucas Peréz

By Walter Broeckx Arsenal team to start: Martinez, Maitland-Niles, Holding, Gabriel, Gibbs, Elneny, Xhaka, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Reine-Adelaide, Akpom, Lucas On the beach: Macey, Bielik, Sheaf, Dasilva, Zelalem, Willock, Mavididi A very mixed team at the start from Arsenal. And with only kids on the bench. A few experienced players like Gabriel, Gibbs, Elneny, Xhaka, The Ox …

Forest v Arsenal updates and Bellerin “has Barça DNA in his blood.”

By Tony Attwood This morning we came up with our scientific prediction of the team: Oooooospina Debuchy  Holding Gabriel Gibbs Elneny The Ox Adelaide Perez  Akpom Willock So what has been going on since? The main story about Arsenal seems to be a re-run of last year, that Bellerin is about to leave.  The alternative story …

Ref Review: Arsenal – Southampton; a perfect example of how the new instructions to refs affects the flow of the game.

By Usama and Walter ARSENAL vs. SOUTHAMPTON COMPETITION: English Premier League MATCH NO. 4 DATE: 10th September 2016 VENUE: Emirates Stadium (London, England) MATCH OFFICIALS: REFEREE: Robert Madley 1st LINESMAN: Marc Perry 2nd LINESMAN: Edward Smart 4th OFFICIAL: Simon Hooper First Half Fouls, Advantages, Cards, and Penalties Time Foul by Foul For Description & Decision …

Nottingham Forest v Arsenal – the scientifically selected Arsenal line up.

By Tony Attwood When the transfer doorway creaked closed once again we published a table of the players in the 25 and the leading youth players who could also play. In the old days this was irrelevant with league cup matches when groups of youngsters some of us had hardly heard of appeared on the …

The PL time wasting problem: it is far worse than you might think, and is being exploited

By Walter Broeckx and Usama As in the Southampton match the keeper of Southampton was booked for time wasting Usama took the trouble to have a look at how the time wasting was going on when Forster had to take goal kicks. We didn’t examine the time wasted on throw ins as that would take …

Arsenal after five games; the statistical analysis. (Hint: the number of shots doesn’t count).

By Tony Attwood A lot of people got very exercised about the Arsenal need to buy another striker or three during the summer.   We bought one, and in this weekend’s game he came on, on the 88th minute. Last season Giroud was our top scorer with 16 goals.  So far in the league he …

West Ham United: Revenge of the tax payers

By Tony Attwood Just back from London, following attendance at the wonderful wedding of Blacksheep and Dru – and for me an overnight stay at the Highbury Hotel on Seven Sisters. Looking at the results yesterday and catching up on the football I missed, what struck me very much (and my only evidence is Match …

Hull – Arsenal 1-4 : Cracking Xhaka goal at the end

By Walter Broeckx Only a few changes to the starting XI for this match after the midweek match against PSG. One of them being Cech back in goal and in attack we had Theo taking the place from The Ox who dropped to the bench. No place for Giroud who had a little problem that …

Hull v Arsenal – the great Hull / Arsenal competition, and an Untold wedding

By Bulldog Drummond This is part two of our preview – for the team and the earlier bits please click here. Hull City caretaker manager Mike Phelan has not got too carried away with his opening results, saying, “There is a bit of belief now and hopefully we can cement our place outside the bottom …

Hull v Arsenal: a guess at the team, injury news, bits and stuff…

By Bulldog Drummond So the marauding Twatters have been busy this week, calling for the manager to go, and it was nice to see Untold fighting back with #CurseTheStar #CurseJackWilson.    I await news of the demise of both the paper and the journalist. In August it was reported that Hull City could soon be yet another …

Hull v Arsenal, Saturday 17 September 2016. The Match Officials

by Andrew Crawshaw The referee review from the Southampton game is waiting for Walter’s input on his return from holiday as there were a number of controversial decisions which require his input. For our game against Hull the match officials are :- Referee – Roger East : a 51 year old from Wiltshire who has …

Post-Truth football: the 20 myths they want you to believe but which are absolutely not true.

By Tony Attwood Over their past two editions both New Scientist and the Economist (two of the most respected and serious weekly magazines published in the UK) have both run editorial comments on the fact that we are now in the era of Post-Truth. In the era of Truth, the truth was the fundamental from …